You've Got Me Helpless

Found Out

"I love you Y/N..always and forever..."

Angelica pulled back up in the parking lot of your apartment, quickly hopping out and locking her car as she dashed in. Eventually making it to your floor, she found your room and knocked on your door. When she got no answer, she knocked again. She heard shuffling on the other side of the door and soon was greeted by the door opening. She smiled up at you as you welcomed her in. "Hello again, [Y/N]. Thanks for allowing me in," she said as she stepped in beside you.

     You shut the door behind her and smiled. "No problem. If you're looking for Eliza, she's asleep on the couch," you say, stretching your back slightly. "Why is she on the couch? I figured she'd be in your guest room again," the brunette replied, an eyebrow raised. "Ah. You see, she and I fell asleep on the couch last night. She and I are kind of....a thing now," you replied, scratching the back of your neck nervously. Angelica gasped loudly, then hearing her sister wake up. And soon enough, the sleepy girl came waltzing into the room, rubbing her eyes before spotting her sister, who almost immediately ran to her and picked her up, twirling her around in the air.

"A-Angelica! What are you doing?!" Eliza yelped. Finally, Angelica put her down, and you scratched your neck nervously again, laughing. "Y/N told me about you twoooooo!" The brunette cooed. "Sh-she did?!" "Mhmm! Although, she didn't tell me how. Y/N? How did it happen?" Eliza was quick to jump to her feet, nearly tackling her sister to the ground as she covered her mouth, then pulling her into the guest bedroom. Once the door was closed and locked, Angelica managed to squirm out of Eliza's grip. "What was that for? Y/N was fixing to tell me how you two started dating!" "I can tell you, I'm just not really comfortable with being a nervous reck around her..." "Why? You're always a nervous reck around her."

     Eliza glared at her sister before sighing. "I know, I know....but....I'll tell you instead." "Good. You'd better not lie about it either because I will get Y/N to tell me." Eliza took a deep breath. "Alright. S-So....wh-what happened was....I sat her down on the couch last night, and after a while, I told her I liked a girl. She asked who it was, and I eventually confessed it was her. And then...she kissed me....and then I kissed back....and then we agreed that were dating..." Eliza looked up, only to see a huge smile plastered across her sister's face.

     "S-So...I'm wondering if....you accept me and Y/N as a couple now..." "Of course I do! I've been trying to get you two together for years!" Angelica laughed as she spun her sister around again, causing the younger sister to yell in surprise. After Eliza steadied herself, she sighed and smiled warmly at Angelica, then hugging her tightly. "I'm just glad you found someone who'll treat you better than that Icarus you were dating a while back." "Yeah. I'd prefer if we never talk about him again." "Understood. So what are you planning to do for your first date?" "F-F-First...d-date?"

     "Yeah! I mean, you can't just jump into a relationship and not spend time with her. You've got to show her how much you love her! I was thinking. My husband and I could help you two find a reservation for a fancy dinner. What do you say?" Eliza thought for a moment. "W-Well, that does sound awfully conscientious of you and your husband, but I wouldn't want to waste your time or money. I—" "Nonsense Eliza! We both know that John works at home and I stay home to help out around the house. And plus, we have plenty of money from father. I'm sure he wouldn't mind if we used it for you." Eliza sighed and nodded, her shoulders slumping in defeat. She knew her sister wasn't going to give up so easily, so she figured she should just allow her to do what she thought was best.

     "Fine. But don't make me feel like the villain if something goes wrong." "I won't. Anyway, I'll go back home and talk to John about it and we'll figure this whole thing out. But you have to make it a surprise for Y/N, got it?" "Got it." "Alright. I'll see you later then! Take care, Eliza!" "You too." With that, Angelica made her way out the door, and eventually, she made it out of the apartment, not forgetting to say one last thing to you. 'You're going to love what we have in store for you.' Of course, you didn't understand what that meant, but you weren't going to question it either.

     So instead, you just said your farewell to Angelica and eventually went back to the living room, where Eliza soon joined you on the couch. When the two of you sat down, you stayed there in uncomfortable silence for what seemed like forever. Your hand eventually found its way to Eliza's waist and you sat beside her to where your thighs were touching. You saw her face fluster as she rested her head against your shoulder. "S-So, uh.....Eliza....." "Y-Yeah?" "What did Angelica mean?" "What?" "She said I'm going to love what y'all have in store for me. What does that mean?" "E-Ehm......well, I'm not really supposed to tell you about it...."

     [A/N]: Hey! Sorry it's been over a year since I've updated this story. I've honestly lost interest in Hamilton, but I'll try to get back into it for a while so I can finish this book. This chapter is really old and I hardly edited it, which is why it's so different compared to my other stories. I'll try my best to update it more often, but it may take a while. Hope you enjoyed!