Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

~When You Move On~

Jeff the Killer

A/N: Bf/N = Boyfriend Name

"Hey, Y/N..." Jeff commented,  staring straight at your new boyfriend, "Who's this?" He looked dangerous,  more so than usual. His hair was messy, and his eyes were piercing straight through your boyfriend.

"This is Bf/N... We've been dating for a week now," You look away from Jeff, glancing at the ground. You and your boyfriend were headed to the store because your parents needed some stuff for food. Bf/N just came along for fun.

"Oh... You move on fast..." Jeff was now looking at you, his hands inside the pocket of his hoodie. One of his hands was wrapped around his knife.

You shrugged.  Bf/N was holding your hand, glaring at Jeff, "I know you hurt Y/N, you pathetic freak. Get out of our way."

Jeff's smile twitched, "Freak?"

"Yeah. You're only putting Y/N through unnecessary pain," Bf/N growled.

Jeff pulled out his knife, clenching it tightly in his hand, "Let go of her before I send you home in pieces,  Motherfucker."

Bf/N stood his ground and you stepped in, "Get lost, Jeff... I hate you. I want nothing to do with you."

Jeff put the knife back in his pocket, hanging his head, "Y/N, I need you... Please... I love you."

"Fuck off," You replied and pulled your boyfriend passed Jeff. The two of you continued to the store.

*********

Slenderman

"You're so cute," Your new boyfriend smiled, booping your nose. He toyed with your hair that was draped over your shoulder for a bit.

"I would have to agree with that," Slenderman sighed, leaning again the tree beside the bench you were on.

"Slenderman, go away," You hissed.

"I miss you," If he had a face, Slenderman would've frowned.

"I don't care," You growled.

Slenderman sighed, "I know... By the way... I had to get a different phone to call you... You smashed my other one, remember?"

"This conversation is pointless," You were glaring at him.

Slenderman glanced at your boyfriend, "Nice meeting you, Bf/N. Take care of her because she deserves better than both of us." He then teleported away.

*********

Eyeless Jack

"I'm in love with you still!" Jack grabbed your hands,  going down on his knees, "Please, Y/N. Take me back. I'm so, so, so, so sorry! I never meant for you to get hurt."

"Get up..." You sighed, ripping your hands out of his grasp.

Your boyfriend walked out of the coffee shop, "Y/N, who is this guy?"

"My ex," You replied, taking one of the coffees/teas from your boyfriend,  "He was just leaving."

Jack stood up, black tears running down his cheeks behind the mask, "I fucked up, Y/N. I'm so sorry... Please... Believe me."

"No." You brushed passed Jack, you boyfriend following.

*********

Laughing Jack

"Y/N, I thought you were mine... You moved on?" L.J asked worriedly, "I can't lose you like this! I can't handle knowing you're in this world without me!"