Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

~When You Take Him Back~

Jeff The Killer

You woke up, your head pounding. Your mouth tasted awful and you smelled like a bar. You didn't even know what day it was! Why were you in a bathroom? Why was someone laying on the ground next to you?"

"G'morning," Jeff murmured, sitting up.

You let out a scream, which only made your head throb more, "Why are you here?!"

"Uh... Because I didn't want you dying?" Jeff replied, "You were throwing up most of the night and I didn't want you drowning in your own vomit..."

"Do you have to be so graphic?" You started to feel queasy.

"I suppose not. By the way, you owe me twenty bucks," Jeff said.

"What why?!" You asked.

"I totally held my liquor better than you did, plus I held your hair back all of last night. Also, I kept those douchebag dickfucks away from you at the bar. I think I at least deserve twenty dollars if not a second chance," Jeff replied.

"You... You held up my hair?" You wondered.

"Yeah..." Jeff nodded, "You look kinda cute with smudged up makeup... Not so cute while you are hurling though..."

"Thanks," You rolled your eyes.

"Just keeping it real," Jeff shrugged. You still couldn't wrap your head around the fact that Jeff had taken care of you all of last night. Emotions started flooding in and you lunged towards him for a kiss.

Jeff held his hand up in front of your face, "Brush your teeth first." He stood up and left the bathroom.

You ended up showering, and cleaning up before taking Jeff back. He was more than ecstatic when you finally took him back.

*********

Eyeless Jack

Jack had went all out. He took you to a fancy, schmancy restaurant and bought you flowers. You two were sitting at the table,  awkward silence filling the space between you two.

"So... Was she a better kisser?" You asked, referencing the girl he cheated on you with.

"Uh... Why do you want to know? I just want to have a redo first date, okay? No talking about what I did," Jack frowned underneath his mask.

"Well you kind of screwed up, so-"

"Y/N, this isn't fair... I have this one date to make things right... Please give me a fair chance," Jack sighed. He reached across the table and grabbed your hand, "I'm sorry for the past, but that's exactly what it is!"

You sighed, "Fine... I'm sorry too... I'll try to be more understanding."

"Thank you," Jack was relieved.

The rest of the date went smoothly and you ended up taking Jack back. This made him quite happy and you were slightly happy because you still liked Jack and he was yours again.

*********

Laughing Jack

The fair was back in town and you figured you might as well go down to check it out. The rides still looked lame and so did the new food booths. However,  there was one booth that was familiar.

Laughing Jack's Candy.

Children were lined up, all excitedly looking at the candy selections. L.J was not in the mood to kill so none of the candies were poisonous and he wasn't interested in learning the names of the children.  He looked empty, no hope... Lonely...