The Risks We Take (Natsu X Reader) [ON HOLD]

🍋🍋Change and Confusion🍋🍋

Ever since the truth came out that I'm a girl things have been getting better. The guys that would always bully me and Natsu and beat us up came and apologized. Sting and Rouge have since started questioning if they are bisexual since they got turned on that one time watching me and Natsu. Gray is questioning his sexuality as well since he thoroughly enjoyed me sucking his dick when me, Natsu and him and a threesome that time. Even Lucy is wondering about herself.

Seems we've made quite the commotion.

Me and Natsu are now acing all of our classes and everyone is stunned, especially master mavis. She knew he had potential but she never expected me to bring it out.

Now they are considering Co-Ed dorms with the help of match maker Mira. She's setting everyone up but obviously leaving me and Natsu alone. Our grades alone are proof that we are good together. Our teachers are happy to see Natsu improving and now keeping up my grades despite all that has happened.

Me and Natsu are currently in our room doing our homework when there's a knock at the door. Natsu gets up to go answer it and see's gray standing there.

"Hey Gray whats up?" Natsu asks curiously

"Bro. I'm confused. Help me?" Gray replies looking like he's in a lot of mental pain

"Sure bro. Come on in." Natsu replies now looking extremely curious and confused himself.

Gray enters and goes to sit on the couch by me. I feel uneasy for some reason so I scoot away slightly. Gray sighs and looks at me sadly but with lust in his eyes. He closes his eyes tightly and lets out a loud groan.

"Guys. Help me. Ever since that night with you guys I've been wanting to mess around with girls! I never liked girls before but when Angel sucked my dick it felt so damned good!" Gray shouts and put his face in his hands.

"So....you like my girl?" Natsu asks with annoyance and anger in his voice.

"No! Yes? No? I don't know man! I'm confused. Is it her or just what she did? Help!" Gray begs and looks like he wants to cry.

Natsu sighs loudly. "At least you told me I guess. I'd rather you be honest than just sneak behind my back. So what do you think will help you not be confused?" Natsu still looks pissed off but is controlling it.

"I don't know Natsu!" Gray shouts and leans back on the couch and takes a deep breath.

I have a idea. I grin and look at Natsu who looks at me with concern at what I'm thinking. "Ever had sex with a girl Gray?" I ask while still grinning.

Both of them look at me wide eyed. Gray looks at Natsu and Natsu looks at me like I'm insane.

"What?" I ask innocently

"No Angel. No. No way. Not happening. No." Natsu says firmly and with anger in his voice.

"Sheesh it was just a question." I pout and look away

"No I haven't. I'd like to though." Gray says sadly "just to see if I like it."

I look at Natsu and he glares at me.

"Oh come on Natsu. You can join in to. Just a one time thing." I say in a pleading voice.

Natsu continues to glare at me and I glare right back and shift uncomfortably at the thought of another threesome with them. Natsu fucking gray and Gray fucking me at the same time. Damn I'm horny already just thinking about it. I look at Natsu and he looks amused. He knows why I'm squirming and what I'm thinking.

"Gray. You have condoms still?" Natsu asks and gray nods "have them on you?" He shakes his head no "go get them." Natsu says with a grin "bring a bunch." Gray looks at him surprised and nods and stands up to leave.