Unlikely (Nerd! Fresh x Jock! Paperjam)

Chapter Twenty-Nine

*Fresh POV*

"Alphys I can't go to school..." I whined. I was still so upset by my breakup and I haven't been to school in the last three days. Alphys came by to check up on me.

"You can't stay home forever! You have a GPA to handle!" Alphys said, stomping her foot like an irritated mom.

"I know I just... I don't want to see PJ..." I say and looked at my feet, embarrassed.

"Well ignore him. Get ready we're leaving in a hour." Alphys ushered me into my room and closed the door behind me. I sighed and started putting on clothes. Excepting my fate.

When Alphys and I arrived at school, I kid you not everyone was staring at me.

Undyne quickly came up to us, panting like she just run a marathon.

"Fresh! You're here finally! I thought you died or something!" Undyne said and gave me a big hug, which surprised me a lot cause she never gives hugs.

We began to walk down the hallway and people are still starting at me. "Undyne why is everyone staring at me?"

Undyne's eyes get wide then quickly turn into a sorrowful look. She looked so sad it almost made me cry.

"Well... let's go somewhere private to talk about it... c'mon let's go outside in the courtyard." Undyne said. Alphys and I followed her and Alphys wore the same sympathetic look.

We sat down at a tree where no one was near so no one could hear us.

"So... word got around that you and PJ broke up..." Alphys stayed. I looked down. I had kinda expected it.

"How though? Only we know about my breakup and I don't think you guys or PJ is shouting it through the halls." I ask confused.

"Well that's the thing... Bunny found out..." Undyne started. I felt my eyes beginning to water and I quickly blinked them back.

"She told the whole school and spread some rumors... and now..." Alphys choked up, looking like she was about to spit out snails.

"Now what?" I ask, wanting her to finish.

"Bunny somehow got PJ to date her." Undyne said quickly but slowly enough for me to understand. I was surprised at myself when no tears came down my cheeks and I looked down with a bored expression.

"I'm tired of crying over him then. He found the one right for him finally. I'm glad he's happy." Undyne and Alphys give me a sad look and the bell rings. They both give me a small hug and head off to class.

I grab my book bag and start heading down to class when I see him...

He looked like a total mess to be completely honest. He was wearing a button up shirt which didn't look like the buttons line up correctly, he was also wearing jeans which he never does, he usually wears athletic shorts. He had huge bags under his eyes and his hand was connected to a certain furry paw...

Bunny looked like she had a fresh bath or something cause she didn't take note of PJ's appearance at all. She was in a dress, which sorta matched with PJ's button up.

I turn around immediately and head straight down the hall.

*PJ POV*

After three days of constant worrying and trauma, Undyne said to me that Fresh was coming to school today.

When I saw him talking outside in the courtyard to Alphys and Undyne, I couldn't help but notice that he looked like a mess like me. We both sloppily put on clothes and have massive bags under our eyes.

"PJ I told you not to wear that shirt today! I told you to wear the other one! Oh my gosh this is so embarrassing." Bunny screeched in my non-existent ear.

Fresh wouldn't care if I wore a hotdog suit to school. He would probably just laugh and except my fashion sense and style.

I don't know why I said yes when Bunny asked me out. I think it was that I would forget about Fresh and maybe actually be happy with Bunny.

Oh boy was I wrong.

Bunny grabbed my hand and pulled me through the hall, occasionally stopping when someone was talking about a rumor or something.

Fresh would have taken my hand gently and led me through the hall, not stopping but checking on me every three seconds to make sure I was still following him.

I want to be with Fresh again so bad.

but I know he doesn't want me.

Everything was a lie. I don't know how to feel. Should I feel furious? Sad? Should I be beating up Fresh for lying to me that entire time?

Even if I was supposed to I would never. Fresh is more to me than anything in the entire world. I would hate to loose him, but I already have.

I saw Fresh walking toward us in the hallway then quickly turned around when he saw us. I wanted to run after him and give him a hug from behind, whisper in his ear how cute he looked when tired, and how much I loved him, so so so much.

Unfortunately not all dreams come true.

And they become into nightmares.