Unlikely (Nerd! Fresh x Jock! Paperjam)

Chapter Thirty

*Fresh POV*

I decided to deal with my feelings I would write down things that I hated about PJ and why we shouldn't have ever dated.

I started that two weeks ago. The page still remains empty. As my heart.

It's been three weeks since PJ and Bunny have been going out and I believe I have forgotten my feelings.

I don't know how to be sad or happy anymore. I just feel so so empty.

It's an awful feeling, when you know you want to feel but you physically can't.

I haven't been to school at all this week and my grades have been getting worse and worse. I've also been skipping sleep cause my mind won't stop thinking.

Everyday I go to school just to see if PJ had broke up with Bunny yet. Now I've given up.

but sometimes there is light in the deep dark hole i call darkness.

*PJ POV*

"...and that's what actually happened! PJ please please please believe me!" Undyne and Alphys begged.

I couldn't believe it.

Bunny had lied.

I had always denied Undyne and Alphys trying to get me to listen to the 'real story' but I always declined. I didn't want to hear how Fresh never liked me and was dating me just because he felt sorry for me.

But I finally listened. And I'm so glad I did.

I know what happened.

But how do I approach Fresh now? He probably hates me now!

I stared at Undyne and Alphys, who was still begging me and waiting for my answer.

I answered with a stray tear rolling down my cheek. "How do I get Fresh back?"

Alphys smiled brightly and Undyne looked as if she was about to faint out of happiness.

"I've got a plan! It may take a while to work but it will definitely-"

"Let's do it." I cut Alphys off, already agreeing. Desperate to have Fresh back into my arms again.

"Fresh loves cliché things so I was thinking you could do The Secret Admirer thing and give him notes and goodies and then when he wants to meet up you can meet up with him and apologize." Alphys said. I smiled.

"That's cute and all but how is PJ gonna do that if Fresh doesn't even go to school?" Undyne asks.

"Don't worry i'll make sure he comes." Alphys said and rubbed her hands together.

I smiled as the bell rang. I have to still deal with Bunny. I know just how to do it too.

*Time Skip*

"Bunny I need to talk to you." Bunny and her friends stepped forward. "Alone." I demanded. Bunny looked behind her angrily and shooed off her minions. Then smiled sweetly at me.

"Okay Paperjam!" She giggled. I gagged when she wasn't looking.

I took her to the back of the school then pinned her to the wall so she couldn't move.

"I know what you did to Fresh." I stated. Her eyes went wide as she squirmed.

"I don't know what you're talking about..." She stuttered. I scoffed.

"I'm breaking up with you but it's not like I ever wanted to be with you in the first place." I let go of her as she angrily stomped toward the doors.

"Oh and also.." I said getting her attention. "If you do anything to Fresh I will make sure you're expelled." I growled. Bunny looked as if she was gonna cry then ran back inside. She was probably gonna spread some more rumors. 

I quickly ran inside the opposite way she did into the lunchroom. I quickly ran on stage and grabbed a microphone.

"Is this on?!" I quickly asked. Some people closest to me nodded their heads.

"Okay! Hi! If you know me good! If you don't know me then my name is PJ, I'm on the basketball team. You will probably also know me for either dating Fresh or Bunny. Well recently I broke up with Fresh because I thought he didn't love me. Well cruelly it was Bunny and her friends who planned the whole thing to make me break up with Fresh so she could date me. That's all I wanted to say. Please note that Bunny is an absolute disgrace. Thank you for your time." I put the mic down as Bunny, from the corner of the cafeteria, stared at me in shock that I just did that.

Everyone started talking rapidly at once and the quiet cafeteria became as loud as a party. Everyone seemed to be on my side. 

I walked off stage and Undyne and Alphys came up to me.

"I feel way better now."

~•~
*Unedited*
779 Words

while i was writing this i realized PJ isn't just gay he's bisexual cause he's dated fresh and bunny....

i'm so confused about his sexuality WHAT IS IT

maybe pansexual??

IM SO CONFUZZLED SOMEONE PLEASE HELP ME

but guys omg i cry every time y'all say you love this book it's sooooo amazing how much support you guys give me i love every single one of you

thank you for frikin' 13 thousand reads that's a lot

but hey guys have you heard of the new game 'Deltarune' i'm so confused on what it is so far but omggg i love it so muchhh

and don't forget to check out my other account @EeeWheezy where i post BTS fanfics and just normal cute OC fanfics.

can you guys give yourself a pat on the back like you guys are living isn't that like... so cool? life is a beautiful thing don't hate it please.

I LOVE YOU GUYSSSSSSS