Unlikely (Nerd! Fresh x Jock! Paperjam)

Chapter Twenty-Eight

*PJ POV*

I walked as slow as I could to Fresh's house after school that day. I had felt awful ever since that girl gave me that note.

I had to do this though. To make Fresh happy.

I approached his house and knocked on the door. I heard shuffling and Fresh opened the door.

"Hi PJ!" He said and smiled. He had some comfy looking shorts on with a grey sweater and a blanket wrapped around his shoulders.

"H-Hi Fresh.." I blinked rapidly so tears wouldn't fall down and gave him his homework.

"Are you okay?" Fresh asked. He gestured for me to come inside but I stayed put on the porch.

"Listen Fresh... I'm so sorry about everything that you've been going through. I've thought about it and all your suffering has been caused by me. Every rumor, fight and other stuff all happened to you just because you were with me. I'm sorry I had to put you through all of that." I started. Fresh looked very confused.

"I-I think we should spilt up. Not because I don't think we belong together just for your self esteem and well being. I'm sorry I had you go through all of the miserable stuff." I said. Fresh stood there with his mouth hanging open. Probably from shock.

I took a deep breath, said goodbye, and walked off.

Tears uncontrollably rolling down onto the sidewalk below me.

*Fresh POV*

What the heck just happened?!

I had set up a bunch of things for PJ and I to do when he got out of school and then he....

breaks up with me?!

That's the worst thing he could do to me.

I sat there on the couch. His words still echoing in my brain. My face was stained with previous tears and my head hurt from crying to much.

I quickly got my phone and called Alphys.

*Call*
(F=Fresh, A=Alphys, U=Undyne)

A- Hello?

F- A-Alphys...

A- Oh my gosh Fresh you sound terrible! What happened?

F- P-PJ.. He broke up with me...

A- What?! Why?! What happened?!

F- I have no idea... he just came to my house and basically said he felt bad for all the pain I go through being with him then just said we have to split up. I'm still so confused....

A- Hang on I'm gonna call Undyne and add her to our call

U- Hello?

A- Undyne PJ just broke up with Fresh for no reason

U- What? I thought Fresh wanted to break up with PJ

F- WHAT?! Where did you hear that?! I would never want to break up with PJ!

U- That's what PJ told me, he said a girl gave him your note-

F- What note?!

U- He said a girl came up to him in the hallway and said that you dropped the note in Math class and that she was gonna return it to you but gave it to PJ instead.

F- What did it say?!

U- Well PJ didn't read it to me but he summed it up for me. He basically said that the note said you were tired of all the physical and mental abuse that you get from dating him but you didn't want to break up with him because you felt sorry for him and would feel bad.

*silence*

F- I never wrote that note!

U- Are you sure? PJ said the handwriting was similar.

F- Wait...

A&U- What?

F- I have a girl in my math class that has almost the same handwriting as me... our teacher noticed it one day when she forgot to put her name on the test... she was a skeleton too and I've seen her sit at lunch with Bunny...

U- Oh...

A- Oh my god.

*End of Call*

*Bunny POV*

"Why are you here Luna?" I snarled. We were at Starbucks and Luna came bustling through the door. "You do recall me kicking you out of the group know do you?"

"Yes Bunny but listen. I did it. PJ and Fresh broke up." She said. I stopped then narrowed my eyes.

"Prove it."

Luna got out her phone and quickly pulled up a video of her giving PJ a note.

"I gave PJ a note that told him that was staged to look like Fresh wrote it. Fresh and I have very similar handwriting-"

"You idiot!" I screeched. She jumped back alarmed. "We already wrote a note to PJ! He's not going to believe it!"

"B-But Bunny! He d-did!"

I stopped. "Again. Prove it."

Luna got her phone again and switched to another video which showed PJ crying on the sidewalk walking up to someone's house. The camera moved what looked like into a bush near him and you could barely make out Fresh opening the door and PJ saying a long paragraph and 'I-I think we should split up.'

I looked up at Luna suprised.

"Luna, your back in." I stated. Luna smiled and muttered a thank you.

"Tomorrow PJ is my priority. I am not leaving school until he and I are dating. Here's how we are gonna do it." I made sure everyone at the table was listening.

~•~
875 Words
*Unedited*

What a turn of event

OMG THANK YOU GUYS FOR 10K READS!!