It was raining hard down on the small town of valentine as Arthur Morgan, the infamous Dutch van der linde's right hand man was riding back to the gangs camp well hidden just outside the small town.
When arthur arrived he was treated by the stoical idiot bill Williamson.
"Who goes there?!" Bill shouted.
"Its me arthur!" Arthur excliamed.
"Oh hey morgan, I left you a little something on your table for that hair pomade, oh and you got a letter from that girl what's her name? Martha?" Bill said.
"Alright thanks Williamson. Its mary." Morgan said feeling his chest tightening.
Come morning time morgan had risen and begain reading a letter from Mary who was asking him to help her and she was staying outside Valentine on a ranch. He gripped the letter and was departing immediately but he got stopped by the Gang Accoutant, Leopold strauss.
"Herr Morgan! Are you busy today I have a debt that needs collecting, alot of money." The old Austrian said.
"Well strauss I was on my way to town to meet an old flame." Arthur said feeling a bit frustrated.
"Well if you would be so kind head over to the downes farm, try to get there quickly I heard they are skipping town. Anyway good luck with your lady friend herr morgan." Strauss said.
"Later Herr Strauss!" Arthur said waving to the old man.
Arthur took his time riding to marry
with all the things racing around in his mind. He shaved up for his clandestine meeting with mary as he didn't want dutch to think he was running off with her since his old friend seemed to be slipping lately. Part of arthur wanted to sweep her off her feet and settle down in some quiet town but a few hundred dollars and a bounty well into the thousands on his head made his fantasy seemed well just that, a Fantasy. He couldn't abandon dutch eaither his best brother and closest thing to a father, arthur couldn't just throw away those decades he had with him at a wim but the time to think soon came to as arthur reached the farm.
Arthur removed his hat as he knocked at the door waiting nervously and only to turn around to a lady holding a gun.
"Yes?" The woman said.
"I'm sorry but I didnt mean to disturb you ma'am but is mrs. Linton in?" Arthur said.
"I'll go see." she said disappearing back into the house.
A short moment later mary exited the house and her and Arthur's eyes met creating a moment pure awe between the two.
"Mary." he said.
"Arthur." She said.
"I erm.. uh." Arthur stuttered.
"Oh arthur I heard you and your friends where in town and i-." Mary cut herself short.
"Where uh.. erm... what's his name?" Arthur awkwardly inquired.
"He died of pneumonia." Mary said.
"Uh I'm sorry for that." Arthur said.
"I'm sorry too." She said.
"So are you here looking for me or?" Arthur asked her, deep down he'd hope she came for him but he knew it has his help she needed not his love.
"Listen arthur, my family- I need your help." She stumbled over her words.
"You mean the family that always looked down on me?" Arthur got defensive.
"No arthur its jamie." She said.
"I always liked jamie. Atleast compared to the rest." Arthur proclaimed.
"He's gone and broke daddies heart." She said.
"Daddy has a heart?" Arthur trivially asked.
"Arthur! Please he's gone and joined the chelonians, they ain't right. They are going to get Jamie killed!" She pleaded.
Arthur contemplated for a moment and thought up a scream that'd make cupid blush.
"I'll get Jamie but afterwards you'll have dinner with me? As f-friends of course." Arthur said.
"I'll think about it." She said.
"Alright. I'll go get jamie." Arthur agreed as he ran off to his horse.
A few hours later after a run in with crazies and arthur beating Jamie in a duel, Jamie finally agreeded to come home and Arthur hoping Mary would at least entertain his proposal. The two rode back to valentine and soon arrived at the train station to mary patiently waiting for Jamie then soon seeing him explode with glee and squeezing the young man with a hug and afterwards turning to arthur.
"Arthur thank you for bringing little Jamie home, and about dinner, our train is delayed so I thought why not slip out for a moment but where in valentine could we possible have a proper meal?" She said.
"Well I was thinking I could cook for us." Arthur suggested.
She had a hearty laugh then said "arthur everyone know you ain't a cook! The last time you cooked for me you put mint on pork!".
"Now that was a recipe dutch gave me from one of those oriental books! I'm better-Just humor me." Arthur pleaded.
"Ok I'll give you one chance." She said.
"Alright I'll be back when I'm done cookin'." Arthur said.
Arthur took a trip down to the butcher and bough the best cuts of steak he could get and a trip to the general store and bought a fine aged brandy, afterward he went to a quiet wooded place outside town and set a blanket down then lit some candles, set out some dishware, then cooked the prime beef cuts with oregano. After all was done he collected mary and was slowly walking her to the romantic spot.
"Why did you blind fold me arthur? You aren't holding me ransom are you?" Mary asked.
"Of course not! I want this to be a surprise." Arthur said.
"I was only kidding." She said.
"Good because where here." He said untying her blindfold.
Mary was greeted by the sight of the romantic candle lit dinner, the nicest thing anyone had ever done for her.
"Oh Arthur this-this is so nice! The most beautiful thing anyone has done for me!" She said and turned giving him a hug.
"I'm glad you like it." Arthur said as a warm wave washed over him due to Mary's excitement.
"Well lets get eatin'." Arthur said taking a seat and grabbing a plate and mary did the same.
Mary cut into the thick steak and took a bite the exclaimed it was "very good arthur! You have learned at least something in your robbing and killing sprees.".
Arthur shrugged and grabbed the brandy "care for some brandy my lady?" Arthur said smiling.
"Of course gentle sir. Mr. Morgan the romantic who would have thought?" She said reaching her mug out.
They both ate and sipped their brandy for a few moments until mary finally built the guile to ask arthur a question "Arthur. This is so nice but why are you doing this? We aren't starry eyed kid no more.".
"Well mary all these years I still haven't got over you, I think about you more than I should." He said putting his plate down.
"Oh arthur I can't lie I've thought about you all these years too! Even with my husband." She admitted.
Arthur sighed.
"So what is that you want Arthur Morgan?" She asked.
"Just you. Right now." He said as they both reluctantly begain to kiss.
The shy kisses soon turned into passionate kisses they turned into them both half naked. Arthur planted kisses on Mary's neck as she ripped his shirt open exposing his hairy chest that she's missed all these years. Soon arthur was slowly kissing her from her neck to her vagina.
"Arthur!" She moaned pushing his head into her.
Eventually Arthur made his way inside of her as they soon came together and peacefully went to sleep in each others arms.
YOU ARE READING
(Arthur x Marry) RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 Arthur's Paradox
Fanfic-Spoilers- What if after Arthur saves Marrys brother and afterwards Arthur and her sleep together? causing an entire different story to unfold in which arthur doesn't contract TB but must choose between his life as a outlaw and his "family" or give...
