Some time pasted since arthur and mary last saw each other but regardless of what happened mary had still contacted arthur asking for help, she was staying in saint denis and the gang had set up camp not to far outside the sprawling city so its no coincidence why she contacted him. The real problem was getting into the city undetected due to all the heat dutch has been garnering on the gang with his and micah's hair brain schemes. After a time of thinking arthur decided to disguise himself amongst the city, a suit, a tie, some shiny shoes, hair slicked back and he was ready to mingle among the elite of St. Denis. It wasn't a very long ride into the city but arthur felt an uneasiness wash over him and it wasn't the feeling of civilization but facing mary after what had happened a couple months back. He arrived at her hotel and she called out to him from the balcony "Arthur over here! Wait for me to come down".
Arthur rubbed his teeth "clean" with his finger and mary came rushing out of the hotel and gave him a big hug.
"Oh arthur you came. Things haven't been making sense lately, I'm just glad to see you." She said joyfully.
"I'll always be here whenever you need me, what's wrong?" Arthur said.
"Arthur i-im-its-huh!" She tripped over her words.
"Mary what's wrong?" Arthur said while grabbing her and looking into her eyes.
"Arthur it's just uh- ITS Daddy!" She blurted out.
"Oh daddy huh? What's he gotten him self into now? Forgot to pay his bar tab? I get all dressed up like this and risk my life sneaking into the city just to save a man who hates me?" Arthur said.
"Arthur please he's begain pawning things off and I think he took my mothers broach and plans to sell it." She pleaded.
"Alright what's the the old loveable patriarch up to this time?" Arthur said.
"Oh arthur you know sarcasm is beaneath you." She said.
"Ain't nothing beanth me, let's go." He said.
After a day of following Mary's father around St. Denis and getting her mothers broach back, arthur and mary decided to go to a play together.
"Alright mr. Morgan will you walk me to the trolley?" Mary asked.
"Of course ma'am." Arthur said.
"Well that was quite ridiculous but really fun." Mary said holding onto Arthur's arm and leaning into him.
"It was better than I thought it would be, listen mary, I'm sorry about what happened a few months ago back in valentine." Arthur said.
"Which part?" Mary asked.
"Uh killing those guys of course, I wouldnt trade the night we had for nothing." Arthur said firmly.
"Oh arthur its quiet alright, I'd be God knows where doing who knows what if you didnt kill them." She said.
"Well we are here." Arthur said removing his hat.
"Listen arthur, daddy wasn't the only reason I was here looking for you." Mary said.
"Whadda mean?" Arthur asked Putting his hat back on.
Mary grasped both Arthur's hand with her own and looked deep into his eyes and said " Arthur what happened a few months ago, I'm well pregnant.".
"W-what?" Arthur said.
"I'm pregnant Arthur and I cant do this without you, I've realized I cannot be happy without you but now I really need you. Our child needs you." Mary said while starting to cry.
Arthur hugged her.
"I know you have that moral code of yours to live by and loyalt but will you run away with me and raise our child?" She pleaded with tears running down her face.
"Listen nothing on this God forsaken world would please me more but we need money if we are going to live normal. And this thing with dutch is about finished but I need to make sure the people I look after are taken care of too." Arthur said.
"I know you wont run away with me. Goodbye arthur, I'll write you." She said.
"Wait! Mary take this to show you I'm serious, this thing with Dutch is over! It won't be much longer, just wait for me and buy a small plot of land and a nice house to go on it. Here should be over eight-thousand dollars." He said giving her bundles of cash.
"Alright arthur-just dont die please." Mary said.
Arthur kissed her on the cheek and said "I love you, both of you."
"I love you too arthur morgan." She said while getting onto the trolley as it departed.
"Write me when you get us some land!" Arthur screamed while walking away. Arthur had been a father before but this was different, it was mary this time and it meant a chance at a normal life with someone he truly loved but for now arthur headed for camp to change out of his fancy suit.
YOU ARE READING
(Arthur x Marry) RED DEAD REDEMPTION 2 Arthur's Paradox
Fanfic-Spoilers- What if after Arthur saves Marrys brother and afterwards Arthur and her sleep together? causing an entire different story to unfold in which arthur doesn't contract TB but must choose between his life as a outlaw and his "family" or give...
