Creepypasta Headcanons

51.) Sally/BEN Drowned/Slenderman

Here's how everyone found out that Sally hated milk:
They were sitting down at breakfast and Masky was drinking his 2nd cup of coffee.  BEN put a glass of milk in front of Sally.  Sally stared at the glass for 5 minutes, looked at BEN, hurled the cup at him, and threw a temper tantrum.
That was the ONLY time Slenderman put her in timeout.