Creepypasta Masky x Reader. [Cheese Cake]

Cheese Cake

It had been three months. Three months since your breakup with Masky. You had still felt betrayed and your thoughts haunted you. He told you you were beautiful, you trusted him with your past and even trusted him when he said you shouldn't kill your father. You'd found out your father was long gone, moved to a different country with his new wife and Dominick. You sat on your bed looking at the wall and rubbed your temples. You've both ignored each other unless it had to do with business or if you were bickering over stupid things. You moved your (h/c) locks out of your face and fiddled with the knife in your hand. You didn't have patrol tonight, it was Toby's, Jack's, and Jeff's turn. Jeff was off the ban but Slender still had Jack keep an eye on him. You'd gotten in trouble a few times due to your anger but you made it up. Getting up you walked out of your room and went to your comfort place, the library. You walked down the dark hall and then opened the large double doors and entered the room full of books, closing the door behind you you walked to the red plush couch and took a deep breath. You grabbed the book you were currently reading—which you had left on the coffee table. You got lost in the words and failed to hear the doors open. Suddenly the couch dipped as weight was put on it, you recognized the smell of cologne and cigarettes and you felt your heart beat faster. Unfortunately you still loved him, even after everything. You didn't dare look at him, it'll hurt too much. You flipped the page but could no longer keep focus.
"I'm sorry"
His deep voice cut through the thin air. Did he really just apologize? You laughed lightly to yourself and put your bookmark in your book and set it on the coffee table.
"Sure you are," you said and picked your nails. "You were right, people like us, we can't feel emotions like that. It was dumb to start it... it was foolish of me to trust you" you whispered the last part but the way he shifted told you he heard you. He stayed quiet. "Now you won't talk huh? Wow. You know I trusted you with a lot of shit, I really did. You just wanted me for sex didn't you? I bet that's it" I said as I felt my blood boil thinking about it. "You're not answering so I as-" you were cut off by a pair of cold lips against yours and you pushed him away but he wouldn't budge, he held the back of your head so you couldn't leave the kiss. Your heart ached and you kissed back missing the feeling of Masky being by your side. He parted slowly and whispered across your lips.
"I miss you." He gulped. His eyes were focused on your lips as you looked at him with shock. He misses me? Does he mean it.
"I don't trust you" you whispered and he sighed and pulled away, you missed his warmth already. Suddenly he lifted his hand and wiped your cheek with the pad of his thumb. You didn't notice you started crying. How weak you felt.
"I-I was scared, I didn't know how to feel about these new feelings and it hurt to see you storm out. Leave just like that. Ignoring you was hard, it really was and I hated every single minute. I hate myself for hurting you..." he said and you were about to talk but he pressed his finger against your lips and took it away once you shut your mouth. "(F/n) you made me feel things I haven't felt in a long ass time. It was wrong to hurt you" he moved closer and brought you into a hug and buried his face in your neck, his dark brown hair tickling your neck. You slowly wrapped your arms around him. Is this a trap? It could be right? But you hugged him back anyways.
"Masky, I trusted you with everything. You stabbed me in the back" you whispered as you brought your hand up to run your fingers through his hair.
"I know, and I was foolish. I really was, I was scared of my feelings and ran away. God I'm so dumb. I miss you" he kissed your neck gently and held tighter. Fuck it.
"I miss you too..." you whispered and felt tears falling down your face.
"Can we try again?" He asked after a few minutes. You debated it. Should you? You bit your lip and slowly nodded deciding to give him another chance. He lifted his head and leaned in for a kiss but you stopped him and looked him in the eyes.
"Let's take it slow, please" you whispered and he nodded and you took your hand away. "But if you hurt me again... I'll stab you in the back." You smiled slightly and kissed his forehead and he bit his lip and gulped.
"Okay"
The End

A/N: sorry for the bad ending?? I hope you liked this book. Love you all. Comment below if you think I should rewrite it.