Creepypasta Preferences and Scenarios

Who Said I Love You First

Jeff the Killer;
He did. On accident.

Homicidal Liu;
You did during an argument.

The Huntress;
You did.

Jane the Killer;
She did it while she was sleeping and you heard her.

Clockwork;
She yelled it in the woods while you were sleeping. You're a surprisingly light sleeper.

Slenderman;
You said it right before you told him about Lelia. (If you decided to adopt her or found out you were pregnant with her.)

Splendorman;
He did when you went on your first date.

Trenderman;
(If you're a girl) You said it while giving birth to Morea.
(If you're a boy) You said it after getting baby Morea.

Offenderman;
He said it when you were asleep.

Zalgo;
After you became his "girl/boyfriend/partner."

My theydy.