Jeff and Max were watching Finn getting rimmed by Coach, who was kneeling on the floor with the big first baseman's legs draped over his shoulders, Finn's hairy blond butt cheeks were cupped in his hands, both thumbs in his crack, spreading his cheeks apart as Coach's curled tongue drilled into him. "I'd fuck him now, Coach," Jeff recommended as Finn began to moan. "Can we watch?"
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"I don't mind if they watch," Finn said after Coach lowered his legs to the floor, signaling that Coach agreed with Jeff that it was time. "Quietly, then," Coach replied.
"I was thinking that stuffing my cock into Finn's mouth while you're splitting him wide open," Jeff suggested, "would help hold down the noise level by muffling his screams, so it sounds like we're on the same page, Coach. Plus, I've recently confirmed that sucking a huge cock can have quite the soothing effect, so you might want to incorporate into your new cherry removal program having your virgins give you a blowjob along with fucking you twice."
"I'm not ruling out sucking on your watermelon dick pacifier, bro," Finn replied, "but I really want to focus on what getting fucked feels like. We'll see."
"Jeff, I meant for YOU to be quiet if you're going to stay," Coach said pointedly. "No running commentary from you."
"Now when have I ever done anything like that?" Jeff asked. "But if I had done that, you should've punished me, Coach, when you had the chance, and you've had plenty of chances. Now, though, you've let me become all incorrigible and shit. Hey Max, are you checked out on liquor yet? I'm about to hang a 'contributing to the delinquency' charge on Coach by hitting his bourbon. You want to help me?"
"I'll have a little," Max replied. "Maybe that'll cut through this strange taste of well fucked ass I've got in my mouth."
"Max, that really was some incredible fucking," Jeff said as he went to find some bourbon mouthwash for Max. What he was thinking was that the taste in Max's mouth could only have been 'best fucked ass,' because his ass had never been fucked better, but it would have been bad manners to say that in the presence of two other guys who had fucked his ass very well.
Coach had talked with Finn earlier about the optimal positions for a beginner to get broken in (and standing against the shower wall was not one of them). Coach explained that basically any position that pulls the 'victim's' knees toward his chest is usually the most comfortable (i.e., the easiest in which to get a big dick all the way up the dude's ass), like the 'victim' lying on his back with his knees pulled up to his chest or on his hands and knees, ass up, with head and chest tucked, and a couple of others, all four of which are essentially the same from an anatomical standpoint. Finn opted for the face to face version, on his back with his knees pulled up, which had the advantage of allowing for kissing, which he was into. His choice hadn't excluded the possibility of him sucking Jeff's pacifier, but Finn on his knees probably would've made a mid fuck blowjob easier to accomplish.
"Hey Finn, let's do this in the bedroom," Coach said, "you'll be more comfortable. Max, we're probably going to need your pacifier in Jeff's mouth to keep him reasonably quiet...if he's his usual irrepressible self, be ready to gag him."
"Not a problem, sir," Max replied as Jeff caught up with them in Coach's bedroom.
"Thought you could hide from me, huh?" Jeff asked. "Hey Finn, you ever see that movie 'There Will Be Blood?'"
"I must've missed that one," he said, lying back on the bed, ready for Coach's hard cock.
"No matter," Jeff said, "the movie doesn't have shit to do with what's about to happen, I just wanted you to be thinking about the title."
