Creepypasta zodiacs

Zodiac #12

Some of you reenact a scene from a show together, here the scene:
You know that scene in brooklyn nine nine where Jake (I think thats his name) gets the criminals to sing "I want it that way"
This one:

Those of you who reenact it are:

Capricorn, Leo, Virgo, and Aquarius

The Pastas who do so with you are:
BEN, Ticci Toby and Jeff

Your roles:

Capricorn: Jake

Leo: 1

Virgo: The woman

Aquarius: 3

BEN: 2

Ticci Toby: 4

Jeff: 5

How it plays out

Capricorn: *serious expression* Do you recognise any of these men?

Virgo: I was hiding in the bathroom stall so I didn't see his face, but I heard him. He was singing along to the music at the bar.

Capricorn: Can you remember what he was singing?

Virgo: I think it was that song "I want it that way"

Capricorn: *grinning* Backstreet boys, I'm familiar. *clears throat and tries to look serious* Number one, could you sing the opening to I want it that way.

Leo: Really? *Visible confusion* Okay.. *sings* You are my fire.

*Capricorn looks at virgo, who shakes their head*

Capricorn: Number two, keep it going.

BEN: *looks at Leo, confused and sings* The one desire.

Capricorn: Number three! *smirking*

Aquarius: *Singing* Believe when I say

Capricorn: *Full on grinning* Number four!!

Toby: I want it that way.

Capricorn: TELL ME WHY!

Others: AIN'T NOTHING BUT A HEART ACHE!!

Capricorn: TELL ME WHY!

Others: AIN'T NOTHING BUT A MISTAKE!

Capricorn: *singing* Now number five!

Jeff: I NEVER WANNA HEAR YOU SAY!

Capricorn: WOO!

All but Virgo: I WANT IT THAT WAY!

Capricorn: Chills, literal chills.

Virgo: It was number five, number five killed my brother.

Capricorn: ._. Oh my god, I forgot about that part...