Sally Face X Reader // Oneshots And Lemons

Cheater! Sal Fisher x Reader V.2

April 16, 2020
[Cheater Sally Face x Reader]
Rewrite for Angst!  People were upset over the last one so I rewrote it with a different ending.
Hints of Larry x Reader at the end.

Christiiiinnnneeee

You walk into school with Larry alone, mainly because Sal had woken up early to walk with Ashley. You sigh boredly and see Sal at the front with Ash as they talk.

She seems to have noticed you because she went in for a hug with Sal, you'd think Sal would push her away considering the fact that he wasn't really open to anyone, physically or emotionally.

Instead, he hugged her back. This of course hurt you deep inside, you had been dating Sal for almost 7 months and he only ever accepted side hugs from you and only 3 times did he ever properly hug you, at first making you feel as if you were important.

You were starting to have doubts about your relationship with Sal, recently he would be hanging out with Ash more than you.

Multiple thoughts would race through your mind, Sal wouldn't cheat on me.. would he?

You finally calm down after a small minute breakdown.

You walk up to your boyfriend and Ash, "S-Sal.. let's go to class before the bell rings.." You say nervously.

You could see him from his prosthetic, that he was looking at you.

"O-Okay." He simply stated and started walking with you, and on your way to class he glanced back while you weren't looking.

As the day went on you and Sal had not been making much communication.

But oh did he talk to Ash..

During lunch you didn't see your boyfriend anywhere, you sat next to Larry as he was talking to some other kid.

As you were all chatting away, Travis passed by with his small group of friends and spilled his yogurt on your pants as they all laughed and walked away avoiding communication with you guys,

"Hey what the hell man!" Larry yelled out, "It's fine dude, I'll go clean off in the restrooms.." You saying sighing in annoyance.

You got up , and started heading out of the cafeteria, you start walking towards the restroom and walk in,

You hear giggling and whispering, assuming it was just those girls who caked their faces with makeup you grabbed a paper towel and started rubbing the yogurt off, as you turned around to the corner,

"S-Sal...?" He was kissing Ash while pinning her to the wall making you feel sick to your stomach, almost wanting to throw up.

He turned around quickly and immediately jumped back, while Ash was smirking.

"Are you serious..!" You yell out.

"W-wait- Y/n- let me explain. I wa-!" He said panicky.

"Sal, there is literally no fucking excuse for cheating.." you say walking out with tears threatening to spill out.

Time Skip

Afterschool you didn't bother waiting for Sal, neither for Larry. You immediately ran home

You tossed your backpack in your living room and ran upstairs to your room.

You heard footsteps running and your door opening, rushing to your bed to sit on your bed was your mother.

"Honey what's wrong??" Your mother said.

"I just h-had ab-ad d-d-day" You say trying to control your twitches.

"What happened?" She asks.

"Mom.. when dad left and he said he still loved you did you believe him?" You ask. 

Your mother caught on, "Honey is it about Sally Face?"

"Mom, please answer me." You say.  At that she sighed.

"No, I didn't believe him.. if he had the audacity to betrave our marriage the way he did, I knew the love in our relationship started to drift into an abyss.  When he left to be with that other woman he said that he was sorry.  I knew he wasn't though.  Honey, you and Sally are just teenagers, you've only dated for a short time.  If it took him 7 months to betray you, imagine how worse it would have resulted in if you were committed into a more serious relationship..listen I would love to tell you more but I really have to go with your aunt right now."  She got up a little hesitantly.  She left closing the door behind.

You sigh and sat in bed,

A few minutes later you heard a light knock, assuming it was your mother you said "C-Come In!"

You were turned around drying away your tears.

"Y/n.." You heard a soft voice.

You shot up out of bed in anger, "What are you doing here Sally.."

Sal seemed to have flinched at the name, never in your relationship with him did you ever call him that, except when you were friends.

"You really have the nerve to s-step here.."

"I can explain! I don't like Ash! I never did!"

"Yeah and the explain why I saw you two making out in the restrooms with you p-pinning-g her." You say with less emotion in your voice.

"I pushed her back and she pulled me with her! I was so caught up I didn't react!" He said crying while he started feeling frustrated.

"I-I'm sorry.. she made me kiss her!" He cried out, fidget with the straps of his mask and taking it off.  His face and scabs visible. 

You looked at him.  "I'm sorry Sal, but sorry isn't enough.  You know how sensitive I am with liars.  It took me so long to get you to love me back, and if Ash is what you want then go to her.  Maybe you shouldn't keep her waiting like you did to me."

He shook his head no. 

"No, Y/n please listen!  I love you!  Not her!  I'm so sorry!"

"Sal, if you were as sorry as you say you are you would have said something sooner!  Instead all you got was breaking my heart with every moment you and Ash were together!" You yell at him.  He groaned out in frustration.

"Sal, please just get out.." You say closing your eyes, signaling to the door.

He finally gave up and left.

You hadn't seen him after.  You decide that maybe you shouldn't worry and care about him anymore.  From that day on you had began talking a lot more to Larry.

He was the only one who knew either way.

A week later you saw Sal again, but he wasn't alone.  Ash had him around like a dog.  She was putting something in her locker.

Poor him. You sarcastically think.

As you and Larry pass by him, he pulls off a little play. 

"Well babe, this is my class." He said.  You blush and smirk.

"Alright, I'll see you during lunch."  You say and lean in to give him a kiss, to which he was surprised but didn't mind.

He entered the class and you kept walking.  You drop the pen that was hanging off the pocket of your hood and turn around to pick it up.  When you do you see Sal through his prosthetic practically jealous.  You smiled at him and made your way into the class you were about to be in with him.