Glee Horror Story

The Blame Game

"If it wasn't Brittany, it has to be Santana," Sam accused. Tina shook her head.

"Look at her," she pointed to Santana, who was still crying over Brittany's body, "She wouldn't let Brittany die," she explained.

"So it was Blaine," Puck said.

"Why are we all obsessed with who's involved in the game? We should be focused on who can help us get out, and we should get rid of those who can't," Mike sighed.

"So you voted her," Santana glared at Mike.

"No... I voted Artie. I'm sorry, but you're in a wheelchair, how are you gonna help us escape?" Mike asked.

"I'm smart, I can help still. Someone can wheel me out," Artie replied.

"What if we have to leave in a rush? You'll just get left behind," Rachel shot back.

"Seriously? Out of line, Berry. We're not leaving our friend behind to die," Quinn rolled her eyes.

"You had no problem letting Britt die," Santana scoffed.

"I'll have you know I voted Puck. Kurt's right, you trying to leave right before we started the game seems fishy," Quinn said.

"Maybe Santana was right and your boy toy knew it was coming, that's why he was so silent," Puck shot back.

"Maybe it was Mercedes. She pulled the board out of the box," Finn pointed out.

"Oh, hell to the no, Hudson! You're the one who had Mike read the rules to see if we could just not vote like you had some regret for making us all play," Mercedes claimed.

"I think it was Tina. She was the first to point the finger, she was trying to take the heat off of herself," Kurt spoke up.

"You were pretty quick to defend Blaine. Know something we don't, Hummel?" Puck asked.

"Maybe he was defending me because you were out of line to accuse me in the first place. I still think it was you who started this whole game," Blaine stated.

"It was him, she did it, this one is innocent- God! Will you all shut up for once? Brittany is dead, one of us is next. We need to stop screaming at each other and think logically about this," Santana stood up and walked over to the others.

"Vote," the voice demanded.

Puck was first to vote, and decided to go with Blaine once again. Santana, wanting revenge for Brittany, voted Tina. Mike voted Finn, thinking Mercedes was right about him. Mercedes also voted Finn, angry that he accused her of being involved. Sam voted Rachel, thinking Quinn was right about her being out of line for wanting to leave Artie behind. Tina voted Kurt for accusing her. Rachel voted Tina, agreeing with Kurt about her being guilty. Quinn voted Rachel, annoyed with her behavior. Finn voted Quinn, afraid she was coming after his girlfriend. Artie voted Rachel, afraid she would actually leave him behind. Blaine voted Puck, still thinking he was wrong for his accusation. Kurt voted Tina, convinced she was somehow guilty.

"All with one vote... Kurt, Blaine, Quinn, Puck. With two votes... Finn. With three votes each, and tied for the elimination-" the voice began before a light beamed onto Tina and Rachel.

"So what does that mean?" Santana asked.

"A revote will occur. Rachel and Tina may not vote, everyone else must vote one of them," the voice explained.

Puck voted Rachel, even him thinking it was cruel to want to leave Artie behind. Santana, still set on revenge, voted Tina. Mike voted Rachel, hoping it would weaken Finn. Mercedes also voted Rachel, wanting to take a shot at Finn's girlfriend. Sam again voted Rachel, disappointed in her desire to leave Artie behind. Quinn also voted Rachel for her past words. Finn voted Tina, not wanting his girlfriend to die. Artie voted Tina, deciding to give Rachel a second chance while also trying to take a shot at Mike. Blaine voted Rachel, being closer to Tina. Kurt voted Tina, still sure she was involved in the game.

"With six revotes, and dead-" the voice began before Rachel dropped dead.

"NO!" Finn shouted, crying over Rachel's body like Santana did with Brittany. Santana, knowing his pain, went over and rubbed his back to comfort him.

"The next round will begin... now. There is no time to accuse," the voice announced.

Quinn was first to vote and decided to vote Puck, thinking he was the next highest threat. Mike once again voted Finn, following Mercedes' claim. Santana voted Kurt, thinking he was too defensive. Blaine voted Puck, hoping he would finally get rid of him. Tina voted Kurt again, still mad at him accusing her. Kurt voted for Puck, assuming Blaine would do the same and wanting to vote together. Finn voted for Quinn, thinking she was the mastermind behind Rachel's death. Sam voted Finn, worried he would want revenge for Rachel. Puck voted for Kurt, thinking everyone would vote him over Blaine. Mercedes voted for Finn, still wanting revenge for his accusation of her. Artie voted for Puck, knowing he had accused the most people.

"With one vote... Quinn. With three votes each... Kurt and Finn. With four votes, and dead-" the voice began before Puck dropped dead. Despite everyone being upset over the loss of another friend, nobody cried over Puck's body.