Glee Horror Story

Two Twisted Tales

"I still think Tina is suspicious for being the first to blame someone," Kurt spoke up.

"We could say the same thing about you continuing to go after her. Or for continuing to defend Blaine," Santana fired back.

"You found the game, you have to be involved somehow," Sam repeated his earlier claim.

"Mercedes is the one who took the board out of the box. Maybe she cursed us," Finn suggested.

"You seemed to regret cursing us which is why you had me check the rules to see if you could back out," Mike continued.

"At least he's not accusing people of being useless just because they're in a wheelchair," Artie mumbled.

"Is he wrong? If we need to be quick, you can't help us," Blaine stated.

"We can wheel him, it's not that hard. Besides if any of us need to be voted because they can't help, it's Finn," Quinn explained.

"Me? What about you? There's not gonna be a beauty contest, what can you do?" Finn asked.

"What can Kurt do? He thinks I'm suspicious for blaming Brittany, but at least I'm trying to help. Running into Blaine's arms and planning your next fashion choice isn't helpful," Tina claimed.

"I find it hilarious how we're talking about a lack of skills and not one of you has mentioned Sam," Santana pointed out.

"Vote. The two with the most votes will both die," the voice explained.

"Great," Quinn sighed.

Mercedes, first to vote, decided to go with Finn for accusing her. Santana voted Kurt, thinking he was the biggest threat to the team. Blaine voted Artie, agreeing with Mike's claim that he won't be helpful. Kurt voted Tina, still finding her suspicious. Quinn voted Blaine, thinking he was okay with leaving Artie behind. Artie voted Mike, hoping that would stop the accusations. Sam voted Finn, annoyed he was coming after Quinn. Mike voted Artie, still thinking he wouldn't be able to help. Finn voted Quinn, angry that she had accused him. Tina voted Kurt, wanting to stop him from accusing her.

"All with one vote... Mike, Tina, Quinn, Blaine. With two votes each, and tied for the elimination-" the voice began before a light beamed onto Finn, Artie, and Kurt.

"Looks like it's time to revote. I know who I'll be voting," Mercedes stated.

Mercedes again voted Finn, hoping he would be eliminated. Santana kept her vote for Kurt, still seeing him as the biggest threat to everyone. Blaine switched his vote to Finn, knowing a few others would be voting him too. Quinn voted Finn, knowing he was coming after her. Sam switched his vote to Kurt, thinking Tina may be right about him being too defensive. Mike voted Artie, hoping he would finally get him out. Tina voted Kurt, still thinking he was too defensive.

"With three revotes each, and dead-" the voice began before Kurt and Finn dropped dead.

"Oh my god!" Blaine yelled, rushing over to Kurt.

"The next round will begin... now. There is no time to accuse," the voice announced.

Artie was first to vote, and again voted Mike for his accusations. Mike voted Quinn, thinking she had too much power. Mercedes voted Tina, not knowing where her head was at now that her target died. Sam voted Santana, still thinking she was involved in the game. Blaine voted Artie, again agreeing with Mike's previous claim. Quinn voted Blaine, still assuming he wanted to leave Artie behind. Santana voted Sam, knowing he was after her. Tina voted Mercedes, not knowing who else to vote without debating.

"All with one vote, and tied for the elimination-" the voice began before a light beamed onto everyone in the room.

"What does that mean?" Tina asked.

"Because nobody involved in a tie can vote, the next death will be decided by a wheel," the voice explained.

"Oh my god," Quinn sighed.

"The wheel has chosen. The next to die is-" the voice began before Mike dropped dead.

"No! Bring him back!" Tina screamed, holding Mike's body.