Half and Half (Oblivious!Eren x Reader x Slight!Yandere Levi)

Broken Promise

Soil was mixed with thick blood streaming down from the titan boy. He can feel pain and sorrow. He can feel the anger behind the man's stoic face. That ice cold glare that sends shivers up your spine. Eren was experiencing a brutal torture for the first time. 

He opens one eye to look up, seeing that his superior had stabbed him on the back and into the ground with a sharp blade. 

"You disgust me." Levi spoke in a calm yet dark voice.

Eren's body began to sting. Each blade held him down to the ground. He was unable to get up without using pressure to his serious injuries. He wanted to tell Levi to stop but all he could manage was a small whimper.

"Why would you even try to steal her from me?" Levi asks.

"Once a thief, always a thief." He commented.

Tears streamed down the poor boy's cheeks. His jaw trembled as he attempted to rise from his pierced body.

"I-I..." Eren croaked, slowly and painfully reaching out one arm to stop Levi from causing anymore pain.

"What is it?" Levi takes out his sword with a new pair of blades, causing Eren to flinch in horror.

"I...." Eren didn't know what to say to Levi. He was too scared to say anything, otherwise, he would just add fuel to the fire.

"Answer me." Levi spoke casually as he stabs Eren's hand to the ground from touching him without any hesitation.

"UUGHH!!" Eren screams through his gritted teeth, unable to endure such great pain that Levi had injected.

"Relax, you'll only feel pain for a short while. First, I'm going to cut off your limbs." Levi stares at his swords, his reflection meeting his dark orbs.

"You used those filthy hands of yours to touch her, didn't you? You'll be fine. Your limbs will grow back again, like a titan. Isn't that right, Eren?" Levi glares at the boy as he constantly trembled in fear.

"St...op..." Eren grunted as he closes his eyes tight, not wanting to see Levi's face, especially when he's angry.

"You want me to stop?" Levi scoffed.

"P-P... Pl-ease...." He sobbed.

"Look at you. You're all covered in dirt." The corner of his lips tugged slightly upwards.

"If you want me to stop, you must never see her again."

Eren's eyes were wide open when he had heard the deal Levi offered.

"Even if you take one second to look at her, you'll never see the day of light again. That is, unless you refuse to accept this offering."

"N-No...." He answered immediately.

"No?... Are you saying that you'd rather die than to never see her again? Either way, you won't, you spoiled brat." Levi commented.

"You're in love with her...." Levi's lips curled into a frown, his eyebrows knitted together with anger to this sudden realization.

He grabs Eren's head by his bed of hair, forcing him to look into Levi's eyes.

"Are you?" 

Eren didn't respond, causing Levi to lose his temper and patience.

"I guess we'll find out." Levi lifted up his sword, preparing to dislocate Eren's arms until...

"LEVI!!!" 

Levi stopped dead in his tracks as he hears you calling. Eren gasps at your sudden appearance, causing frantic tears to fall from his eyes like Niagra. 

"(F-First)....!!" Eren managed to call out your name with all his might from his dry throat.

"Levi! What the hell is going on!!" You ran over and stepped in between Levi and Eren.

"Have you lost your mind!?! That is absurd!!" You claimed.

"I think it's you who has lost your mind. Are you not aware that this titan likes being around you? It makes me sick."

For pete's sake Levi, not everyone in this world is kind! He needs someone who can take care of him!" You argued.

"He is a grown up brat, he can take care of himself."

"Try to understand me! What did you plan to do to him!?"

"I was just about to cut off his limbs." Levi responded.

"Why!?" You panted.

"Don't ask me as if I'm stupid enough not to know that you were with that titan brat." He clicked his tongue.

"Then prove it to me-" Levi's hand latches onto your arm, squeezing you tightly.

"Prove to me that you love no one else but me..." Levi leans in close to your ear, taking quick breaths.

"-Tonight." His hot breath hovers your ear, causing you to shudder.

He then pulls away, giving you a serious look.

"Since the whole party's here, I'll only set him free just this once. But you won't be able to escape from me easily, that is, if you decide to change our plans." Levi cracked his knuckles, turning away, leaving the bloody mess for you to take care of, for he had to meet up with Erwin and Hanji. They must be searching for Levi, therefore, he had to leave and make sure that no one knows what his true intentions were. Honestly, Levi wanted to stay and finish what he started but unfortunately, you had witnessed his attempt of killing the boy. He wanted to drag you along with him but who will find Eren and report it? He knew you would be capable of keeping this a secret, so he left with a slight urge to take you with him.

"There's blood everywhere!" You said in a cautious voice.

"Ngh...." Eren felt tired, he was too weak.

One by one, you removed the blades from his pierced body and threw them aside. You knelt down to pick up Eren, regardless of the pool of blood that stained your white pants.

"It's okay Eren, I'm here... I'm here..." Your voice cracked as you held him in your arms, cradling his limp body.

His head rested on your shoulder. His eyes were closed, now in relaxation. You could feel the slight rapid beat of his heart.

"No one will hurt you again... No one will hurt you... It's gonna be okay...." Tears began to form from the corner of your eyes.

You had failed to protect Eren from harm. You left him to almost die. You felt ashamed of yourself for choosing Erwin and Hanji's suggestion over your better judgment. You felt foolish. 

"Eren, please forgive me..."

"I'm so sorry."