Half and Half (Oblivious!Eren x Reader x Slight!Yandere Levi)

Eren

You approached the cell area, casually walking down the hallway with a smile on your face. Once you made a stop to Eren's cell, the boy stood up from his bed, rushing his way towards you, yet his chained wrists caught him.

"(First)!" Eren exclaimed.

"I'm back." You announced as you entered and sat on your bed across from Eren.

"What happened? DId he do anything to you? Are you hurt? Did he touch you??" Eren asked multiple questions, you didn't know where to start.

"No, nothing bad happened." You wore your happy expression, causing Eren's heart to beat in a normal pace again.

"Ah, I'm happy about that." Eren sighed in relief, sitting up on his bed.

He noticed you were playing with your hands with that wide smile, causing him to wonder with curiosity. 

"What's so funny?" Eren tilted his head, peeking at your face from afar.

"Huh?" You looked up to see him.

"You're so... Smiley today." Eren laughed.

"What's with the cute face? Can you tell me?" He requested.

Feeling that you have nothing to hide, you answered his question without hesitation.

"Levi's back." You clasped your hands together.

"What?" Eren's smile began to dissipate as you continued to explain it to him.

"He's going to be alright again. I'm so glad that things will go back to the way they were. I don't have to be afraid of staying by his side as a subordinate anymore. This is great!" You clenched your fists and shrugged your shoulders up in brief excitement.

"But—-"

"He's going to be normal and he's going back to his sassy attitude and—"

"(Name), wait—-"

"He's going to be Levi again!~"

"(Name)!!" Eren shouted, catching your attention.

Eren isn't an expert at hiding his true feelings towards you. He often shares his thoughts, speaking them.

In embarrassment, the boy hid his face with his palms apologized to you immediately.

"I-I'm sorry! I'm so sorry! I-I didn't really mean to stop you!" He spoke.

"Oh, It's alright, Eren—"

"No! I-It's not alright! I'm not okay!" Eren began to feel slight anger and frustration.

"... Why are you sad? What's the matter?" You jumped off your bed and walked towards the titan boy.

He did not respond, still refusing to show himself.

"Eren, are you crying?" You tried to pry his hands from his face. He frowned and wore a painful expression.

"Why are you so happy about that?" Eren stares at you, his eyes wanting to know everything from yours.

"What do you mean?"

"Why are you happy for him? What did he do to you?" He asked.

"Eren, I'm just saying that Levi isn't going to be the twisted man he once was—"

"But, after everything he's done to you. Why do you want to be with him?? Are you... Going to be his roommate now??" Eren questions you with concern, holding your wrists in a firm grip.

You threw your head back, laughing at his worriedness. 

"No, silly. I'm still going to be here." You giggled.

Eren sighed and embraced you.

"I hate it when you talk about him." Eren mumbled in your cotton shirt.

"... Why is that?"

"Because I'm scared that you'll stop liking me." 

"Psh, that won't happen." You stroked his head, tangling your slender fingers in his soft bed of hair.

"(Name), don't go near him. He's dangerous." Eren pulls away, holding your hand tightly.

"Eren, trust me, everything is going to be alright."

"No, please don't. Don't talk to him...." At this point, Eren pulled your arms and into his grasp.

"..... Eren, he's normal again." You attempted to convince him again.

"No.... Please...." He silently begged.

"He doesn't deserve your happiness... He took everything away from you.." He spoke in a stubborn way. 

"He... He tried to kill me." Eren mumbled.

"Eren..."

"Stay here with me. You won't see him anymore." He smiled softly, caressing your hair.

(CHOICE TIME)—————————————————————————————————

OKAY! THIS IS YOUR DECISION, READER. YOU'VE MADE IT THIS FAR, AND THINGS WILL GET COMPLICATED. YOU HAVE TWO CHOICES TO SELECT. YOU CAN ONLY CHOOSE ONE. BUT I SHALL WARN YOU BEFOREHAND, THERE WILL BE A DOWNFALL OR CONFLICT NO MATTER WHAT CHOICE YOU MAKE SO THERE REALLY IS NO RIGHT OR WRONG ANSWER. YOU ARE SRSLY DECIDING. 

Should you listen to Eren after you've reunited with Lance corporal Levi? 

1) Yes.

2) No.

Please let me know on the comments down below and share your answers. You don't have to offer an explanation. BUT I do want to say: Choose the choice with no ragrets. 

Good luck.