Half and Half (Oblivious!Eren x Reader x Slight!Yandere Levi)

Confessions and Stories

During the night, you were now officially Eren's roommate in the cell. He enjoyed your company. At least now there was a bed in his cell. Two beds, actually. They were placed on opposite sides of the cell room. Even though you were there with him, he was still required to wear chains on his wrists. You explained to Erwin earlier that chaining Eren's neck won't solve anything. He agreed to your argument made that an exception. Candles were out, the atmosphere seemed chilly, and nothing but the drumming sound of falling rain splattering on the rooftop. You sat on your bed, across from Eren's as he sat up on his. 

"It's so dark in here. Without the candles, I mean." You commented in the dark.

"Hm." Eren answered.

A moment of silence struck the room. Chains rattled on the ground every time Eren shifts on his bed.

"(First)?" Eren called to you.

"What?" You fell back on your pillow, staring at the blank ceiling.

"Is it raining outside?" Eren asked.

"Yeah. It's raining pretty heavy." You responded.

"When.... When I was out there alone, I'd get scared of the rain."

"Why is that, Eren?" You lifted up your head to glance at Eren.

"Because.... It was always flashing. And then, there's a loud boom sound." Eren explained.

"Well, that's natural. I mean, I used to be afraid of it too." You said as you rested your head back down.

"Ah... Okay." Eren nods.

Awkward silence fills the air once more.

"(First)?" Eren calls out again.

"Yeah?" You answered.

"Can I... Can I hold you?" Eren requested.

"... What?" 

"I said.... Can I hold you?" Eren repeated.

"Eren, there's two beds for a reason." You replied.

"So..... Is that a no?" Eren asked nervously, hinting that he was feeling hurt.

"Are you afraid of the rain?" You asked.

"No. I don't hear scary noises." Eren responded while he fiddled with his fingers.

"Eren, you should go to sleep." You rubbed your eyes as you yawned.

"But.... I want to hold you." Eren tells you.

"I-I promise, if you let me hold you, I'll go to sleep." Eren pleaded.

".... Alright." You sighed as you got out of bed and walked across to Eren's side.

You sat on his bed as he reached out for you. He grabs onto your wrist, pulling you in. You hesitated to accept his hold.

"What is it?" Eren asked.

"Nothing. I'm just tired." You yawned once more.

"Oh... Okay." Eren wraps his strong arms around your waist, pulling you close to his as he rests his head beside your chest area.

"Hey, (First)?" Eren whispered.

"Hn." You responded.

"Do you like... Levi?" Eren asked.

"Uhm.... Yeah, I do." You closed your eyes, wrapping your arms around his head.

"You don't like me?" Eren holds you firmly, causing you to gasp quietly.

"Of course I like you Eren." You said as you exhaled.

"Levi is... Was my superior. I know he can be a little crazy and all. But I still like him. Not love, but family-wise." You responded.

"Then, do you love me?" Eren asks.

"..... Yes... I love you Eren. Now go to sleep." You responded normally.

"Really?" Eren squeezes you tight again, and this time, you weren't able to breathe.

"Ere---"

"All this time, I thought you didn't love me... I'm so happy (First)." Eren felt a sense of relief washing over him.

".. I can't... Breathe." You gasped for air until Eren realized this and loosens his grip.

"Oh, sorry." Eren apologized.

During your slumber, Eren was sleeping soundly, listening to your heartbeat against his ear. Strangely, he loved hearing the beating of your pulse. It was proof that you were with him. He smiled as he slept, embracing you like a stuffed animal, cuddled against you. His soft bed of hair tickled your neck. You didn't mind that he was this close anymore. You realized it before. You love Eren.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"This is..." Levi opens a folder of documents he filled up in the past years.

"These are your personal keepings. I haven't looked over them but I figured you should." Hanji says as he went over papers.

"It's not helping..." Levi commented as he continuously flipped through contracts, old letters, and a photo.

"Are you sure? Nothing familiar?" Hanji raised a brow.

Levi whips out the small photo and ran his fingers over it, staring into it.

"Who's she?" Levi asks patiently.

"Huh?" Hanji leans in close to Levi, looking at the photo.

Her eyes widened to see that the photo revealed you. In a swift move, Hanji snatched the photo away from Levi, figuring out a lie within a second to cover up your tracks.

"Hey! This was the photo you stole from me a while ago! N-No wonder I couldn't find it!" Hanji stuffs the photo of you in her breast pocket and then rested her hands on her hips.

"What's her name?" Levi asks.

"Huh?" Hanji froze to come up with a plan.

"U-Uh... This is the first time you actually cared to ask." Hanji responded.

"It is?" Levi stares into space.

"Hey, what else do you have there--" Hanji reached for Levi's documents but as soon as she lays a finger on it, Levi slams it closed.

"If I recall, these are my 'personal keepings' so please don't touch them." Levi warned her.

"Um... Okay." 

"So.. About that girl in the photo... Is she your sister?" Levi asks.

"What? Oh, uhm... She's... A-A relative of mine's. She uh.... Disappeared I guess.--- Hey! How would you like to know about your story?" Hanji changes the subject afterwards.

"My story?" Levi repeated.

"Yeah like, how you became humanity's strongest soldier." Hanji says.

Levi stares at Hanji for a moment, then nods.

"Alright. Tell me how I earned this title." He responded.

Hanji begins how Levi was a thug from underground to his corporal status. Everything she explained was accurate, only, Hanji made sure that you weren't included within the story...