Divergent preference

Their/ your secret talent.

Eric: He's really good on guitar and he can sing. If anyone found out though he'd deny them and they'd end up dead.
You: You were the best basketball player in all of Dauntless. Plus you were Erics height so no one blocked you.

Tobias: he's really good with animals. Like amazing. It's crazy.
You: You can paint like no ones business
It's rather artistic but it's the way you express feelings. Like for coping and stuff.

Al: he is a good writer. He wrote stories for you back in Candor since the 7th grade. You liked the way that his imagery was so vivid and amazing.
You: you could do backflips really really well.

Will: he never got chapped lips. That's not a talent that's a super power.
You: you could do hair really really well. Like if someone needed hair done in Dauntless they came to you.

Peter: He told hilarious jokes. But that didn't surprise anyone
You: You were really strong, and since you were from amity that made up for the shock that Peter didn't get.

Uriah: He was super flexible. This surprised everyone.
You: You cans do impressions really well, it always make everyone smile.

Caleb: He can do calligraphy wh itch was odd now.
You: You could do weird things with your eyes.