(Suggestion: Watch only Island, Revenge and Pahkitew and then read my Gwen X OC Total Drama Island and my TDROTI OC Cameo before reading this. Those ones are the only seasons that exist in this AU) After three seasons of Total Drama Island, Revenge...
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
Lacks the entertainment factor and energy of the other seasons, feels rather empty, ruins most of the character development from the last season and has some rather dull villains. Justin was barely used as a villain, and a pretty unimpressive one, and Courtney was more like a spoiled child having a tantrum. I also don't like it at all because... it feels like a filler. It really didn't serve that much of a purpose and wasn't that great. Though I did like it's intro of the Aftermath episodes. Those were kinda fun.
5: Pahkitew Island
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
Has some likeable characters but not many (the ones I liked were Shawn, Jasmine, Sammy, Ella, Pre-Evil Scarlett and Max) and Sugar was an awful villain. I almost stopped watching the season because of how bad and annoying the other characters were. The challenges were quite weak and it's potential was quite wasted. But it's better than Action as it did have some good character development in Shawn
4: All-Stars
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
It wasn't a great season and it did have potential but it was quite fun for me. While it did derail Duncan, Courtney, Scott and Sierra's characters, removed Mike's shtick and it didn't take advantage of it being a crossover season much, I found it to be quite fun. I also have to admit, it had a pretty good elimination order. I just wish they kept Jo around more and Gwen was in the final two with Scott, thus we could've gotten an old hero vs new villain finale. It would've stuck with the season's good vs evil shtick and it could've also been a battle to prove which generation was the best. That and I think Gwen and Courtney were placed on the wrong teams. It also had numerous character derailments.
