OUTER BANKS PREFERENCES & IMAGINES

how they react to you being with another boy while dating

JOHN B:

"Who is that?" John was heavily staring at you and the guy who kept blushing and grinning in front of you.

"Oh that's-" JJ paused. "Actually I have no idea."

"Uh oh. Do I smell jealousy?" Kiara laughed as she sat down.

"No...I just want to know who he is, that's all."

"Hey Jonny" You said with a smile as your approached your boyfriend. He smiled a little and you knew he'd seen that. "He just moved here, he's a pogue too."

"He looked interested to me." Spoke JJ trying to create some drama.

"Was he flirting with you?!"

"No John B! He told me he had anxiety so talking to me was shaking him up a little. Please don't be jealous." You kissed his cheek and he nodded.

"I wasn't jealous..I just wanted to know."

SARAH:

"O M G! Y/N is cheating on you!" Said Wheezie as she pointed at you sitting with a guy. Sarah laughed and shook her head.

"No she isn't. She'd never." And she was right about that yet she couldn't help the intrusive thoughts that Wheezie made linger in the back of her head.

"Well maybe go talk to her. Let's see how she reacts."

"Wheezie no!-"

"Hey Y/N!!!" It was too late for Sarah to stop her sister. Almost immediately you presented the guy aka your cousin. Sarah was positive you weren't cheating on her and she was absolutely right.

POPE:

"I saw Y/N talking with some guy." JJ said as he sat next to Pope.

"Oh."

"Hey don't make him insecure now! Y/N would never cheat on you." Kira replied as she, as well, sat on opposite side of your boyfriend.

"Yeah I know. Anyways , I have to go help my dad." Pope quickly left John's house without another word. He knew you loved him and that you'd never cheat on him but that didn't mean you wouldn't leave him for some better looking guy.

"Jesus christ. Why am I overthinking this? It's just a guy, her friend, that's all." Pope whispered to himself , trying to build the confidence he has held a few minutes ago.

KIARA:

"Don't look now but Y/N is talking with a guy." JJ whispered as he took a sip of the hidden beer he had been sharing with the crew.

"Okay? They're just talking not having sex, chill." Kiara scoffed and gave you a quick glance. You weren't doing anything wrong so why would she have to be worried?

JJ:

JJ was walking down the dirty streets that led to his house. He was looking around and trying to find something interesting until his eyes fell upon you...with another guy. He was smiling and so we're you, you guys chattered and chattered joyfully.

"Who is that?" He whispered to himself. The guy was totally unfamiliar. Could he be your-your lover?

JJ stepped back and left. He didn't want to seem like the jealous clingy type of boyfriend that gets mad at the sight of you with another guy. But he was, he was mad alright. Though he had nothing to do worry about because that guy was you cousin. And he felt stupid when he found out.