Ticcitobyfanfiction Stories

12 Stories

Can't Change Me (Ticci Toby X Female! Oc) by _NessaTheButterfly_
Can't Change Me (Ticci Toby X Fema...by ōᴥ︎︎︎ō
A girl called Carrie Pierce (oc), was just a normal girl, but she was born without a voice. She met a guy called Toby Rodgers in the same school. They weren't that close...
The Shadows Over Us  by MyFriendTheUnknown
The Shadows Over Us by K
When a recently graduated forensic student moves to the Appalachian Mountains to get away from the house and bustle of city life, it becomes apparent that not everything...
His Ticking Heart ~ Ticci Toby X Reader by WildChild289
His Ticking Heart ~ Ticci Toby X R...by QueenOfSass👑
Doomed to a bleak and dark future, merciless and constantly fighting to survive...Toby loved his newfound freedom but what he didn't realize was that he'd completely for...
(DISCONTINUED) Creepypasta 7 minutes in heaven by Noggot
(DISCONTINUED) Creepypasta 7 minut...by Noggot
The story will include (hopefully I can't guaretee cause I might get lazy and give up on this story) EJ, Ticci Toby, Jeff, Ben and maybe more
Kidnapped [Ticci Toby x Reader] by BonneyRAWR
Kidnapped [Ticci Toby x Reader]by 𝔰𝔞𝔱𝔞𝔫'𝔰 𝔭𝔯𝔦𝔫𝔠𝔢
what more do you need to know . its ticci toby x reader . . . okay fine ... you come home from school and you take a looooong nap. you wake up because you heard a nois...
Freaks (Ticci Toby) ((Sequel to Outcasts)) by AngelRAGE
Freaks (Ticci Toby) ((Sequel to Ou...by AngelRAGE
Kerigan had fallen in love. I know right? Cliche. But hey, she never actually thought it would happen either. She especially never thought that the perfect boy she had...
The Tree (Ticci Toby x Reader) by TheRegretful
The Tree (Ticci Toby x Reader)by Dani ~ Aika
"(Name).." Toby was confused. Why are you crying? Had he spoken too loud? Had he frightened you? But those who he frightened usually ran, so why weren't you ru...
Wake Me Up When September Ends ➳ Ticci Toby by xxxliiar
Wake Me Up When September Ends ➳ T...by Lyr <\3
When Y/n was 14, She was just exploring around an abandon building with her friends. Until one of them suddenly disappeared. Later, she was found dead. 3 years later, Y...
Now that I found you  ~Ticci Toby~ by _MyDeathNote
Now that I found you ~Ticci Toby~by Lizzy Vantas
This is a cheesy fanfic I started writing when I was 14 but I have decided to continue writing it until it is finished. :|
Annoyingly in Love by xkennyisdeadx
Annoyingly in Loveby sup
Riley... A brand new Proxy, new to the Creepypasta household, and of course, everything else. Although, there is one peculiar person that loves to annoy and pick on her;...
Trust Taken and Given by xxwhitewolfgirlxx
Trust Taken and Givenby xxwhitewolfgirlxx
A girl named Ashley has known Toby Rodgers for years and has felt like she was in love with him.But when he changes does she still love him or will she leave him never t...