"The past never truly disappears; he remains in the shadows, waiting to attack." No one can say exactly how it all started, was it when Finn turned seventeen? When Madden, the leader of the second generation of Horsemen, Forbade Finn from participating in Devils night? Was that when Finn started to feel watched? Or when Finn received the first note from the stranger? ---- ⭐ Remembering that I am not a professional writer, this is a fanfic written by a fan for other fans. ⭐ That all the ideas I had, including couples of the fanfic, are in accordance with the voices in my head.