I Told Him One Lie (An AfterDeath story)

Part 8: Our First

Thing's were going great! It's been around a month now and I don't think I could be happier. Though most things haven't changed the few that did were amazing.
For one he let me kiss him, which shouldn't be surprising but still it's just woah. Two he actually wanted to sleep with me...and not like that, I mean like actually sleep...but...now that I actually think about it...I wouldn't be so against the idea. But I knew that Geno would be though.
...Ok if I'm being honest, I have been thinking about him that way for a week or two now. But I don't think he wants to atleast not this soon...but then again he did already surprise me once...
(Warning +18 content ahead, you have been warned)
It was a few houres later after I thought that and we were in a bed, I was on my phone when Geno was watching TV.
I leaned over and kissed Geno on the head, he looked up at me confused.
"Hey? What the hell are you doing?"
"Oh nothing don't worry about it"
I started kissing his neck, he laughed and tryed to push me away.
"Haha! Hey stop it, you're being a weirdo"
"What are you going to do?"
"Anything to get you away!"
Geno said trying to hit me but I dodge pining him to the bed. We laughed a bit again, but then he finally said
"Ok, Reaper that's enough"
"Hm?"
"What you wanted more?"
"Maybe~"
"No Reaper, it's time to stop"
I didn't move and he knew that he couldn't move me. He just rolled his eyes.
"Really?"
"Ya"
"Fine, if you'll leave me alone"
"Can't guarentee it"
"Ya right, just hurry up"
I grinned and kissed him. But this time when I kissed him, I shoved my tongue into his mouth odvisely surprising him. He gripped my shoulders and I guess at first tryed to get me off him, but I just leaned in more. Eventually his grip loosened as he leaned in to.
We had to stop, a web of sylvia still connecting our tongues as we breathed heavy.
"You *Huff* son of bitch *Huff*"
"*Huff* Ya, ya"
Again I pulled him in to another kiss Geno didn't resist, well not until I started to take off his shirt. He wouldn't let me and once we stopped kissing he screamed
"Reaper! I never I said that I wanted to do that! What the fuck!?"
"Come on Geno~"
I pinned his wrists and lifted up his shirt, he blushed embarrassed. I ran my fingers down his spine and I saw him restrain what I could only assume was a moan.
Since I did that it spawned his waist and hip ecto. His entire face was now cyan.
"R-Reaper! What t-the hell- Mrg!"
I cut him off as I slipped of his shirt, once I was done he again tryed to push me now being freed from my grip. I didn't move so he swung at me again but I grabbed his hand before he hit me.
"Do you really want to hit me?"
"Well, no ofcourse not! But you won't- Ah!-Aaahh!~ Reaper! S-Stop!"
He moaned as I licked and kissed neck. Eventually finding a spot that made him moan loudly and tilt back his head. I sucked and bit down on his neck making him yelp and then moan louder.
He might've not been expecting it but he was defiantly enjoying it now.
I stopped and looked down at Geno, I now had a...hard, and throbbing 'problem'. I needed Geno and I was hoping that he needed me the same way.
He just breathed, still blushing. He wasn't cursing or yelling, all he could do was lay there.
I ran my fingers down his waist to his hips, stopping at his shorts. I slowly started to slide off his shorts, when Geno wiggled.
"Reap-"
"Sshhh"
I gripped his waist and he stopped moving, I then slid off his shorts, reaveling his bulge. I ran my hand up it making Geno moan again.
He was enjoying this but I knew that I would never get him to admit it.
I began to strip and still Geno didn't say anything, he just looked at me still nervous.
I had on my robe so with one tug of a rope it fell easily, and yes I had boxers on I'm not a weirdo.
I saw Geno look at me wide eyed, and surprised. Apparently he thought I would be small, but I had a bigger bulge than he did.
"Hey Reaper are you sure about this?.. I mean we don't have to..."
"Do you not want to?"
"I...um..."
He stayed silent after that, so I kept going. I knew that if he wanted me to stop then he would have told me by now.
I took of his boxers, seeing his dick, precum already starting to ooze from the tip.
I looked up at Geno and he was odvisely a bit embarrassed.
"What is it? Are you shy?~"
"S-Shut up"
I grinned, I wanted to be inside him. So I pulled down my boxers. Geno was now able to see my throbbing erection. He looked at it wide eyed, I don't think he expected it to be so big.
I bent down, held up by my arms that were now just under his. He was still looking at me nervously.
"Nervous?"
"To say the least..."
He moved his arms and began to fiddled with his hands, looking away from me.
"I haven't done this before, why the hell do think I was so scared..."
"Ya I get it..."
"Haha...ya you might've but I mean with as many jokes you make about-"
"I'm nervous to, just wasn't trying to let it show."
Geno looked back at me he chuckled rolling his eyes.
"Ya right, you're dumb ass can lie to me all you want to try and make me feel better but I think I already know that-"
"So you think I'm joking?"
"Yes?.."
"Really?"
"What?"
"You've been the only thing that has ever let me get this close and is still breathing."
I said that and saw Geno have that realization. He then smiled and said
"Geez Reaper how romantic"
"Oh haha, so you want me to-"
"Don't. Even."
"You're the one that said something"
I said chuckling a bit, Geno laughed nervously to, then looked down and back up at me.
"What to big?"
Geno's face was flushed as he screamed
"S-Shut up dumb ass!"
"What I'm just asking. Don't know why you would but I could try and make it smaller-"
"R-Reaper!"
He again yelled, his face fully blue. I sighed and once again smiled, bringing a hand to Geno's face.
"Relax...I'll be gentle..."
Before Geno could say something I kissed him. As I did I lined up my shaft with his ass. We stopped kissing, he tryed to look down again but I just aimed his head back at me so he couldn't look.
I then rubbed my dick on his ass, I received a quiet moan for a response. I was teasing him and I knew that.
I rubbed on him for a little while longer, then it was time for me to stick it in. Geno was breathing heavy as I grabbed on to his waist and slowly...
"Reaper are you- Ha~ A-Ah~ Ahhh!~ R-Reaper!-"
"Gr- Fuck Geno!~..."
I grunted as Geno put his hands over his mouth to keep him from screaming.
But holy shit, he was fucking tight, it took every ounce of restraint and self control that I had to not abuse the opening right then and there.
I saw him flinching, his eyes locked shut to try and keep the tears in. I knew that this was uncomfortable, and probably painful since it was his first time, and even with his eyes shut he couldn't help but cry.
"Do you not like this?.."
Geno slowly took his hands off of his mouth
"It really fucking hurts..."
"It will feel good"
"Ya maybe... But it still hurts like hell..."
"I know, I'll go slow"
"Wait what- Ah!-"
Geno once agin covered his mouth to keep from screaming as I began to move. It felt amazing for me, but when I saw Geno...he was still crying and flinching awkwardly as his shakey hands held back his screams of pain. But still I continued, still not going very fast.
After a few minutes of slow and gentle thrusts I looked back at Geno, his eyes were no longer shut as I saw them begin to roll back into his skull. Finally he was enjoying this.
I began to pick up the pace, going in deeper and thrusting harder. Geno's spine began to bend and I could barely hear Geno moan out in pleasure.
"Take your hands off your mouth!"
I demanded, but he shook his head no. I reached up pulling his hands away from his mouth, he moaned
"N-No! Reaper~ AH!~"
He gripped on to the bed sheets as i went faster. His spine now bent to the point of snapping, and his head now tilt back exposing his neck. I once agin began to lick and suck on his neck, he moaned more. I kept doing this till I found that spot again, I bit down making Geno scream
"AH!~ MMH-!~ H-HAA!~"
I didn't stop biting his neck as I thrusted, his arms now wrapped around me. I was getting close and wouldn't stop, I grunted out
"Gah- G-Geno I'm close~"
"Your W-What!? Ah!~"
I kept going even after hearing Geno's scream of surprise.
"Reaper! Hold on!~ I'm n-not!- H-Ha!"
He could barely mutter a sentence without moaning.
"What? Do you need some more help~"
Geno didn't say anything, just nodded. I grinned and grabbed his member starting to pump. He couldn't stop screaming and moaning anymore, after a little while of pumping and thrusting he gripped on to me tightly and screamed. I felt his warm seed cover my hand as i stopped pumping. He panted and moaned, I kept thrusting until I finally released. Some of my seed oozed from his ass as I pulled out.
We both breathed heavy, exhausted. I roled off of Geno still tired.
"That was fun..."
"Shut up"
I just smiled wrapping my arms around Geno as he snuggled his head into my chest.
"I love you to Geno..."
I said but I got no response, I looked and saw that Geno had already fallen asleep.
I gave him a little kiss on the head.
"Good night my love..."
I felt my eyes get heavy, I closed them, and slept still exhausted after my time with Geno.