Mirrored Memories (A ShayMien + ShayNoah AU)

Halloween Escapade

Months pass by, and Damien and Shayne were invited to a Halloween costume party organized by their friend named Matthew, who both of them also worked with back in the Disney Channel.

On the day that they received invitations, Damien and Shayne were hanging out in the former's house, watching different TV shows. After finishing an episode of America's Next Top Model's 15th season, Shayne asked Damien, "You got a costume in mind yet, Dames?"

Damien shook his head.

He asked back, "Do you have any costume ideas yet, Shayne?" Shayne nodded, but said afterward, "Although, I'm still thinking about which character has a rarer chance of being done by someone else."

Shayne chuckled softly after that.

Then, Damien asked Shayne, "What character do you think I should do for this costume party?" Shayne replied, "I suggest you do a character that you feel like you can impersonate well. Hell, even if you can't exactly mimic everything about the character you want."

Damien nodded slowly.

A few hours later, and Damien and Shayne proceeded to look up different characters they could do for the costume party. When they were satisfied with their choices, both of them agreed to do each other's make-up at Shayne's house a few hours before the party.

At 8:00 am on Halloween, Damien came over at Shayne's house.

Shayne was making breakfast when he heard Damien knocking on the door. He opened the door and noticed Damien's costume. Shayne said, "What an interesting costume choice, Dames."

Damien laughed.

Shayne then told him, "Come in. I'm cooking breakfast, do you want some?" Damien smiled and replied, "I'll eat whatever you're cooking, Shayne, thank you." Afterwards, Damien went inside.

A few minutes pass, and Shayne cooked another plate of his breakfast for Damien.

Once Shayne was finished cooking, both of them started eating in his dining room. As they finished, Shayne stood up and said, "Dames, I'm just gonna take a shower." Damien jokingly said, "Could I maybe join you?" Shayne exclaimed, "Damien! Oh, my God, you're nasty."

Both of them proceeded to laugh.

Afterwards, Shayne took a shower. When he was done, Shayne wrapped his towel around his waist, leaving his torso exposed. Damien was drinking water when he had a glance at Shayne walking upstairs with only a towel covering himself up.

This caused Damien to choke on the water that he was drinking.

Five minutes pass by, and Shayne called Damien upstairs. Damien immediately went upstairs to Shayne's room and asked, "What's up, Shayne?" Shayne replied, "Could you help me with putting on some make-up? I'm doing a new character, Kari Freaking Miller. I'm basing her off on Courtney's real-life sister, but she's the polar opposite of Courtney Freaking Miller."

Afterwards, Shayne brought out a photo of Kari.

Damien proceeded to help Shayne with putting on make-up. Afterwards, Shayne grabbed a wig that he was going to use for Kari Freaking Miller. Once Shayne finished dressing up, Damien told him, "I'm gonna take a shower too, dude. You got any spare towels?"

Shayne grabbed a spare towel from his closet.

Then, Damien proceeded to take a shower. Meanwhile, upstairs, Shayne was rummaging through his closet to find an outfit that would make him embody Kari Freaking Miller.

Once he finished dressing up, Shayne went downstairs.

After Shayne sat on his couch and watched TV, Damien went upstairs to dress up. When he was finished, Shayne turned around and was shocked with Damien transforming into Amy Shtuzger. He told him, "Bro, you literally embodied that brawny bitch from Clarence."

Damien laughed.

A few minutes pass, and Damien and Shayne start walking their way to Matthew's house. When they arrived, Shayne knocked on the door. Matthew, who was portraying Chucky, opened the door and was shocked at Damien's costume.

Matthew proceeded to look over at Shayne.

He asked, "Ooh, who are you supposed to be, Shayne?" Shayne brought his hand out and said, "Hi. My name's Kari Freaking Miller. I'm Courtney Freaking Miller's sister, but unlike that bitch, I don't have any anger issues, so don't worry about me." Matthew chuckled and said, "Clever."

Afterwards, Matthew asked Damien and Shayne to come inside.

As soon as they went inside, they noticed a karaoke machine. Damien looked over at Shayne and said, "We are totally going to sing, man." Shayne laughed and nodded.

Damien and Shayne proceeded to mingle with every person that Matthew invited for the costume party.

A few hours later, and everyone at the party started singing using the karaoke machine. When it was Shayne's turn to sing, he forgot some of the lines to the song he was singing to. So, Damien started singing along with him so he wouldn't feel embarrassed.

Before the party ended, Matthew awarded Shayne with Best Costume of the Night for his newly created character.

To be continued in Part 7...