Mirrored Memories (A ShayMien + ShayNoah AU)

Valentine's Gets Steamy

Days pass by, and it was Valentine's Day, which was also Noah's birthday.

Since that day was a Sunday, Noah and Shayne did not have to show up to work. Noah's parents cooked a simple lunch for him and his older brothers, since it was their birthday as well.

After eating lunch, Noah received a text from Shayne.

The message said:

"happy birthday to u, baby! r u busy with ur fam 2day? I got u a gift for both Valentine's AND ur special day...

P.S.: tell ur brothers that I wish them a happy birthday 2, bb"

Noah felt happy with Shayne's message.

He thought to himself, "Shayne's such a sweetheart. I'm glad Mom and Dad think the same way about him, too." A few minutes later, Noah suddenly thought of an idea. Noah glanced at his parents and asked, "Mom, Dad, could Shayne maybe come over today?"

Since Noah's parents liked Shayne, both of them immediately agreed.

Matthew, one of Noah's older brothers, jokingly said, "I think I know why you want Shayne to come over, bro." Justin, another older brother of his, glanced at Matthew and added, "I know exactly what you're thinking, Matt."

Both of them started laughing afterwards.

Noah rolled his eyes, texted Shayne that his parents allowed him to come over, and thought to himself, "Here we go." Matthew playfully punched Noah's right arm and said, "Oh, come on, Noah. Don't act like you don't know what me and Justin are talking about."

A few seconds later, Noah's mother asked both Justin and Matthew to stop.

Before Shayne arrived at Noah's house a couple of minutes later, the latter's parents and his older brothers were taking their naps upstairs in their rooms. Noah sent Shayne a text, telling him to send him a text once he's at the house's doorstep.

As soon as Shayne received Noah's instruction, he texted him that he was already at his house.

So, Noah immediately went to the doorstep and opened the door for Shayne. Shayne gave him a tight hug and said quietly, "Happy Birthday, baby! And Happy Valentine's Day, too!"

Shayne then kissed Noah's lips.

Afterwards, Noah asked Shayne softly, "Where's that gift you're telling me?" Shayne whispered to Noah's ear and said, "We need to go upstairs to your room first so I could give it to you."

Afterwards, Shayne bit Noah's left ear sensually.

Noah smirked at him and jokingly told him softly, "Oh, I already know what it is." So, Noah grabbed Shayne's hand, quietly closed the door of his house, and tiptoed with Shayne upstairs to his room.

When they got to Noah's room, Noah gently closed the door and locked it.

As Noah locked the door, Noah gently pushed Shayne to his bed and started making out with him. Deep in their kiss, Shayne started squeezing Noah's ass, causing the latter to moan softly.

Afterwards, Noah inserted his hand underneath Shayne's shirt, started caressing his torso, and continued their kiss.

A few seconds pass, and Shayne pulled away for a while to take Noah's shirt off. After that, Shayne went back to kiss Noah. Shayne was about to take his shirt off, but Noah stopped him. Noah said quietly, "Keep the clothes on, babe. I'm all yours."

They went back to making out after that. A minute passes, and Noah went to Shayne's crotch area and unbuttoned his pants. Noah proceeded to insert his hand underneath Shayne's underwear after that.

This caused Shayne to bite his lip in pleasure.

When Noah felt an erection from Shayne, he slightly slid off Shayne's pants and underwear, which fully exposed his hard cock.

Noah then started sucking Shayne's cock.

While Noah was sucking, Shayne was unable to contain the pleasure that he felt. So, he let out soft moans while telling Noah, "God, you're good at giving head---"

Shayne cut himself off when he let out another soft moan.

A few minutes of fellatio from Noah later, Shayne told him, "Noah, I... I'm gonna---" Noah immediately stopped giving Shayne a blowjob. Then, he took his pants and underwear off and sat on Shayne's face. He told him, "Eat me out, baby."

So, Shayne started licking Noah's asshole.

While he was eating Noah's ass, Noah started jerking his cock off as it got harder. A few minutes pass, and Shayne grabbed Noah's cock and told him, "Fuck my face, babe."

Noah started thrusting his cock in and out of Shayne's throat.

While Noah was fucking Shayne's throat, Shayne fondled his nipples again. When Noah felt that he was going to cum, he pulled his cock away from Shayne's mouth. Then, he told Shayne softly, "I want you in me, babe. But still, don't get naked."

Shayne got up from the bed, while Noah went on all fours.

As Shayne spit on his cock and jerked it slightly, he quietly asked Noah, "You ready, babe?" Noah nodded. So, Shayne pushed his cock in and out of Noah's asshole. While Shayne was fucking Noah, the latter said, "Grab my hair, babe. Choke me, too, if you want."

Shayne refused to choke Noah, so he grabbed his hair instead.

As Shayne grabbed Noah's hair, he pulled him closer and whispered, "You like it when I fuck you like this?" Noah moaned softly in agreement.

Shayne gently pushed Noah back on all fours and started fucking him a little faster.

Once Noah started getting tired of being on all fours, Noah pulled Shayne's cock out and laid on the bed. He then told Shayne, "I want you to fuck me laid down."

So, Shayne went on top of Noah and positioned his cock inside Noah's asshole, while Noah wrapped his legs around Shayne's waist.

Then, Shayne pushed his cock in and out of Noah's asshole again. Meanwhile, Noah's left arm was wrapped around Shayne's back, while he held his headboard with his right hand.

While they were fucking, both of them moaned softly.

A few minutes later, Shayne whispered in Noah's ear, "You want my seed in you, babe?" Noah let go from the headboard, started jerking off again, looked at Shayne, and nodded.

The next thing that both of them knew, Shayne came inside Noah's asshole, while Noah came all over his torso.

Both of them moaned softly as they came together. Once Shayne pulled out, he started felching Noah. When Shayne sucked all of his cum out of Noah's asshole, he snowballed Noah.

Noah proceeded to thank Shayne for his gift before getting cleaned up by him.

To be continued in Part 10...