Michael Afton x Reader (Stay By My Side) {Completed}

Chapter 2

 Y/n's POV:

We arrived at Fredbear's Diner at 8:30. Chris was so excited. Everyone naturally migrated to their own groups; Elizabeth and Chris with their friends, the adults talking amongst themselves, and Michael and I together. At one point I kept noticing Michael bugging and teasing Chris. I walked up behind him.

"C'mon Michael. It's his birthday. Just let him be, at least for today," I said.

"Oh please, we're just having a little fun," he protested. I sighed.

"Just let him enjoy his birthday, it's only one day after all." Michael rolled his eyes.

"Alright, alright, fine." Though he did stop bugging Chris, and Chris took advantage to slip away. Shortly after, I saw some of Michael's friends walk in, though I didn't think much of it.

"Hey, I'm gonna go to the bathroom real quick. Don't do anything stupid while I'm gone, okay?" I said.

"Yeah, yeah, sure."

"Good boy," I teased, patting the top of his head. He narrowed his eyes at me with annoyance.

"Y/n, I swear, don't ever say that again." I giggled slightly then walked off.

As I was gone I couldn't help but feel uneasy, almost sick. I had the feeling that something bad, more so horrible, was about to happen.

"I'm just being paranoid. It's nothing," I told myself.

After going to the bathroom, I walked back inside to the party. At first, I couldn't see Michael where we were talking earlier. I looked around and then noticed him holding Chris and standing next to Fredbear, his friends around him. Tears were streaming down Chris's face, as he looked absolutely petrified. I began jogging over to them.

"C'mon Chris, why don't you just say hi to Fredbear?" Michael teased, lifting him closer to Fredbear.

"Michael! What are you doing?!" I scolded, grabbing his shoulder and turning him towards me.

"I'm just letting Chris say hi to Fredbear," he joked, as Chris had tears streaming down his face, looking scared out of his mind.

"MICHAEL, NO! PLEASE!" Chris pleaded.

"Aw, come on, why don't you just give him a big kiss?"

"Michael, stop it! You're scaring him!" I demanded.

"Oh please, we're just playing around."

"PLEASE, MICHAEL! I'M SCARED!" Chris begged.

"Michael, seriously, put him down! You could traumatize him!" I fumed.

"Oh c'mon, what's the worst that could happen?" Michael scoffed, lifting him up a little higher into Fredbear's mouth when suddenly his jaw snapped, biting Chris's head. I saw Michael's face fill with regret and shock. He brought Chris back down on the floor, his head gushing with blood. I saw Michael's eyes fill with tears as he held Chris up in his arms.

"Oh no... no no no NO! CHRIS! I'M SORRY!" he wept. I stood in disbelief, my mouth agape, not being able to process what had just happened. I felt my eyes filling with tears. Suddenly I heard someone gasp and yell.

"Fredbear! H-he just bit that child's head!" Mr. Afton began running towards us.

"Holy crap!" he screamed, tears forming in his eyes and rolling down his cheeks as he got down on the floor by his two sons. He brought Chris into his arms. "What on earth just happened?!" Michael, sobbing, was unable to catch his breath to answer. Mr. Afton looked up at everyone else.