Yesterday...(March 29th)...The day before his birthday
---------------
"Hey Eren? What do you want for your birthday?" You asked, scooting closer to him. Today, you were at your best friend, Eren's house. You were both enjoying each other's company.
"Anything, why?" Eren's turquoise eyes stared intensely at you, making you blush.
Averting your gaze, you continued, "No! I want it to be special!" Now, you were the one staring at him, making him blush. You both chuckled lightly, and you leaned against Eren's shoulder.
"Okay. I do have something in mind," Eren spoke, a smirk plastered on his face.
Shoot. This smirk. What is he thinking how??
"What is it?"
"I want you." Your face immediately turned fifty shades of red.
"W-what?" You tried to hold in your embarrassment, but you ended up looking like a tomato.
"Haha! I was just joking..." Eren said, but you could see a spark of disappointment flash across his face. Sighing, you got up, and headed towards the door.
"Well, I'll see you tomorrow! You know my mom...She get worried easily." He smiled sympathetically at you, and you bid each other goodbye.
When Eren saw you walk out the door, he sighed and murmured, She'll never like me back though...
-----------(Till the very next day)............
"Come on!" Sasha, your sister, cried, "We don't want to be late for Eren's birthday!"
"Alright, alright! Just some few finishing touches..."
From the corner of your eye, you saw Sasha smirk, "Are you trying to look good for your boyfriend?"
"W-whattt? No! Eren and I aren't dating!" You denied, blushing madly.
"Well, I see that blush on your face-"
"That's my makeup!"
"Aaaand I never said it was Eren! GOTTCHA!" Sasha shouted, happily jumping up and down.
"Sh-shut up..." You cried, covering your face to try to hold in the embarrassment.
"Alright, alright! Let's go!" Sasha grabbed her purse in one hand, and a bag of potato chips in the other. Sometimes, you seriously wonder how she's still skinny.
You grabbed your purse along with Eren's gift and followed her out the door.
(At the Eren's house...)
"(Y/N), welcome! Sasha, welcome!" Carla grinned, sweetly smiling at you both.
"Thanks, Mrs. Jaeger," You and Sasha both said in union. Both of you took off your shoes walked into the house.
"(Y/N)!" Eren shouted, giving you a warm-hearted hug. You hugged back and buried you head into his chest.
"Awww, you two already look like a couple!" Sasha loudly whispered, earning approving nods from Carla and Mikasa.
Both of you flew apart and you specifically glared at Sasha.
"Uh...I-I um..." You mumbled. You and Eren awkwardly walked into the living room, and saw all your friends there. Both of you separated and talked in your own little groups.
"Why were you two holding hands?"
"So, are you two dating now?"
"You both were blushing."
"You guys look cute together."
Your friends gathered around you and began to compliment you and Eren.
"Guys! Stop! Eren and I aren't dating!!"
"Everyone gather around the cake!!" Carla shouted, and everyone ran to the table. Eren sat next to you, and slowly, your hands intertwined. Blushing, you both looked away.
"HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU! HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU! HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO EREN, HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU~" Everybody sang the song and Eren cut the cake. After everybody finished, they began to chat again.
Now is the time (Y/N). It's now or never...
"Hey Eren? Can you come with me for a second?" You mumbled, tugging at Eren's hand.
"Yeah sure..." Eren walked out of the room with you. Due to nervousness, your other hand (holding the present) clenched the gift tighter.
Once you were out of the room, you shoved Eren's present in his face.
"H-here. I-I got you this gift," You blushed turned even darker. Eren accepted the gift, and looked at you for approval to open it. You nodded and watched as Eren unraveled the present inside. A keychain. A keychain with the words I love you, Eren Jaeger carved into it. You looked down at your feet, and million thoughts ran through your mind.
What if he doesn't like me back? What if he rejects the gift? What if, What if h-
Your train of thoughts were cut off when Eren suddenly pressed his lips onto yours. Shocked, your eyes widened. You felt Eren's perfect lips move against yours. Slowly, you melted into the kiss, and wrapped your arms around his neck. Pulling away slightly, you both gasped for air.
"I love you too," Eren murmured, before planting another kiss onto your lips. You gladly kissed back, and you felt him smirk slightly.
Oh, how disappointed you felt when you felt Eren's lips leave yours.
"Hey, remember what I said yesterday?"
"What?"
"The present I wanted. After all the best present is you. I want you."
Extended Ending:
Little did you know, a certain figure was standing behind the door, staring intensely at you and Eren.
----
"DID YOU SEE THEM?! THEY WERE SO CUTEEE~" Sasha shouted, as the crowd scooted even closer, their eyes gleaming in interest.
Carla and Mikasa just stood there, smirking at them.
