From Earth to Paradis (Erwin/Mike/Levi x F!Reader)

Chapter 1: The Four Superiors

Pain ripped through your skull, and your muscles ached from your involuntary stretch. A loud, pained groan slipped through your lips, and you refused to open your eyes, hoping that the pain would subside a bit before you even tried. The aching pain throughout your body was almost enough to convince you that you had been chased and smacked around by a Titan.

You took a deep, semi-painful breath and tried to run a hand over your hair, but something attached to your wrist harshly stopped you.

"Ow! What the fuck?"

Your eyes snapped wide open, and what you found had your heart stopping. The ceiling above you was stone grey and dark instead of the soft white shade of the one in your living room.

No way...

For a moment, you remained frozen, trying to convince yourself this wasn't what you thought it was. But when you turned your head enough to catch sight of four people that should only exist in fiction standing on the other side of the cell bars, you knew this was real.

"Oh, fuck..."

Before your very eyes were the four superiors of the Survey Corps. Erwin sat in a chair with Mike standing to his left and Levi to his right. Hange stood closer to the bars of the cell you were in, and you gasped, sitting up and scrambling as far back on the cell bed that the chains around your wrist allowed.

"O-Ohhh, this is insane. This is fucking insane. I've really outdone myself this time," you whispered to yourself.

You maneuvered your body in a way that allowed you to grip your head despite the chained handcuff around each wrist. Your heart raced in your chest, right leg bouncing a mile a minute. The scrutinizing stares of the four superiors weighed down on you, and you quietly took as many deep breaths as you could to prevent a panic attack. You shouldn't be here.

"You're awake," Erwin stated.

It took a moment for you to make eye contact with him, and you licked your dry lips, searching for the right words to say because everything you want to say made you sound batshit insane.

A sharp throb radiated through your temples, a not-so-friendly reminder of your hangover and likely concussion from the Titan. You winced and gripped your head, massaging your temples and silently praying that this was all some sort of nightmare.

Someone suddenly grabbed the cell bars, and you jerked back. Hange stared at you with fascination, a wide grin spreading across their face.

"Tch, back off, Hange. You're scaring the woman," Levi scoffed before narrowing his eyes on you. "What were you doing in Wall Maria?"

Good question. You would like to know as well.

But Wall Maria gave you some context as to where you were in the storyline. A Titan being in the walls meant Maria had been breached already, and Mike being alive meant this was prior to the Stohess District raid. That gave you five years to work with, and you could narrow that down if you found out more.

"I... I don't know..." you whispered and curled into yourself. "I really shouldn't be here."

Erwin raised an eyebrow. "What do you mean?"

You hesitated. The truth would sound insane to them, but what other option did you have? Lying would only worsen the situation, and right now, you needed as much help as you could get.

You took a few deep breaths and met Erwin's gaze, hoping your eyes convey your honesty.

"You're going to think I'm insane," you warned the superiors, "but I'm not from this world. This... This is all supposed to be fictional. You're all nothing more than characters in a story where I come from. You shouldn't exist."