The image of you right now, displayed in such a lewd manner atop the cotton sheets of Eren's bed bested any of the scenarios the two boys above you had ever imagined about this very moment.
You were their fantasy. A brand new shiny toy to play with, or more accurately, corrupt.
A spitting image of a stereotypical good girl, you spent your childhood and a majority of your teen years growing up in a sheltered home, contributing to your naive and most importantly, virginal status. You vowed that you would save yourself for marriage, that you could never and would never let another man corrupt you. Yet all it took were a few sweet words and some charm from the schools golden boys to watch that high and mighty resolve of yours crumble.
It was a truly pathetic sight to see whenever they'd interact with you. Your nervous gestures and fleeting eye contact always left Jean and Eren craving for more. I mean who couldn't get hard from those twinkling eyes and flustered expressions you made? They just knew they had to have you.
And whatever Jean and Eren wanted, they got.
༻✧༺
"Please, I can't take both, I-I've never done this before", your voice is on the verge of nonexistent, your throat hoarse from all the cries you've let out over the course of a half an hour. Jean had already sheathed himself inside of your virgin cunt, stretching your walls till you felt like he was going to tear you open. Droplets of blood coat the base of his cock as you're seated over him, arms encircling his neck and head tucked under his chin.
"You can and you will." Eren says, as his thumb massages your tight hole. "Now relax for me so it won't hurt, ok?" At this you feel his tip suddenly push into your lubricated ass, a mixture of pain and unfamiliar pleasure cursing through your veins as your muffled cries grow louder.
"Shh baby, it'll be ok" Jean's voice soothes, his hand coming up to massage your waist. The shaft of Eren's cock continues to stuff into your tight muscle only inducing a litany of saliva and tears to gather in a small puddle on Jean's shoulder.
As Eren bottoms out an indescribable fullness overtakes your senses, numbing the remaining pain of his girth stretching your ass for the first time.
"God she's so fuckin tight," Eren astonishes, watching as your virgin hole grips the length of his cock, all the way to the base. "I wish I found you earlier, baby." He chuckles, leaning over your crouched form and grabbing your neck.
He brings your back to his chest as you gasp for air, clawing at the hand around your neck, both of your walls squeezing the men below you, enabling a string of groans from them.
"Yknow what?" Eren asks as a sly smirk forms on his face. "I think you're gonna be our new favorite whore."
