Stuck in the Middle (An Eddievr, Mully, and Juicy Fanfic)

Chapter 9: Caught in the Act (SMUT)

Eddie's POV
After a few hours of being asleep, I felt the bed shift from another body. I let out a sigh, shifting a little when I felt him lay next to me.

How long had I been asleep? The last thing I remembered was being dragged into the house after drinking more than I should've. Hopefully Mully didn't feel his head pounding like I did.

"Mully...?" I muttered, reaching for him. His arm gently went around me, hesitating but then pulled me in closer. His chest pressed against my back, and I smiled to myself. His soft breaths tickled the back of my neck, and I cuddled into his chest.

I felt him grin against my skin, burying his head in my shoulder. He had never done that before, but I didn't stop him. I ran a hand through his soft threads of hair, closing my eyes peacefully. After all the drama with Gaege and the immense hangover from that night, it felt nice for him to have me in his arms for once. My heart skipped a beat, and I suddenly wanted to kiss him.

I turned, our noses touching as I realized how close we were. It was too dark for me to see his face, and I pressed a sleepy kiss to his lips. He was definitely surprised for a few seconds, but gently kissed me back.

For some reason, this kiss felt different, but I couldn't figure out why. Although I couldn't hold back all the pent up emotions within me. His lips were so soft and warm against mine, and his hands ran into my long hair. I moaned into his kiss, grinding my hips against him for a few seconds.

It was until I opened my eyes did I realize something was definitely wrong.

I almost screamed but felt his hand clamp over my mouth before I could cry out. I stared at horror in the person in front of me, and I swore my soul left my body as my mind raced to figure out what was happening.

"Shh! It's okay!" Gaege was lying right in front of me. Gaege. His hazel eyes darted to the door then back to my face, and I shoved his hand away. I sat up quickly, scooting away from him embarrassingly. I put a hand on my chest, trying to catch my breath after the scare he gave me. Although I couldn't wash the blush in my cheeks away, and my heart was still beating a million miles an hour.

"What the hell are you doing here?!" I whispered, suddenly growing angry and confused. "I thought you were Mully!" Gaege sat up, putting his hands up as he explained, "I know, it was a stupid idea! I'm sorry!"

"It's going to take a lot more than just a sorry!" I crossed my arms, feeling tears swelling in my eyes, "Does Mully know about any of this?"

"No..." Gaege avoided my eyes, fidgeting with the blanket between his fingers, "Look, Eddie. I- I didn't mean to do this. I just wanted to experience this again..." I stared at him, unsure of how to answer.
"Gaege, we promised to never do this again," I warned him, "It was once! Mully can't-"

"Forget about Mully! What about you? Us?" Gaege had tears in his eyes as he said sadly, "Whatever the hell 'us' is."

My head still couldn't wrap around how good his lips were against mine and hands running over my body passionately. It was a feeling Mully had never given me or bothered to try. It was the first time in the past year that I felt sparks fly between someone again. I couldn't remember the last time me and Mully had such an intense kiss.

"Fuck," I shook my head, guilt churning in my chest for even thinking that way. "I know, it's my fault," Gaege started to stand, but I grabbed his arm.

Gaege gave me a shocked look, blushing furiously when he glanced at my hand. I pulled him on top of me, lying back down on the bed and locking my lips to his. Gaege jolted for a second before melting into me. I grabbed his waist, groaning when he kissed my neck.