Stuck in the Middle (An Eddievr, Mully, and Juicy Fanfic)

Chapter 10: Gaege's Room (SMUT)

Eddie's POV
I heard him sobbing as I came upstairs quietly. I paused for a few seconds, stopping before I reached the last step. I sighed, knowing I was going to have to face him eventually. The pool of guilt building inside me forced me to place my hand on the wooden doorknob, slowly turning it and peeking inside.
It was silent for a few seconds until I heard a rustling coming from the corner of the room. "Go away!" Gaege's voice was muffled from his runny nose, "I'm leaving."
"What?" I push open the door, only to be met with Gaege piling his clothes into a suitcase. My mouth hung open as I stood there speechless. He didn't want to meet my eyes as he threw his red and black hoodie into the increasing pile of items in his suitcase. His eyes were red and puffy, but he quickly looked away when he saw me staring.
"No, you don't have to help me pack or be concerned about where I go," Gaege waved a hand to me, "I already found a hotel down the street-"
He stopped when I hugged him tightly, sobbing into his shoulder weakly. I couldn't control my emotions anymore, and I buried my face in the crevice of his neck and shoulder as I cried. He was frozen for a moment before slowly melting into my touch. Gaege's hands shook until he wrapped his arms around me, taking in my embrace as he took a deep breath.
"It's okay," Gaege said softly, rubbing my back with his hands, "It'll be alright."
"No, it's not," I shook my head as my voice shook. "Gaege, what the hell am I going to do?"
He sat me down on the bed, wiping my tears gently away with his thumb. "Here." Gaege handed me one of his soft pillows with a small smile, "I always hug this one when I'm sad. It helps me feel better." I glanced over to the pillow he was holding, only to be met with a cute face of a cat imprinted on it. I sniffed, hugging the soft pillow and resting my head on top of it. I didn't meet his eyes, only took in the comfort of him gratefully. The pillow oddly smelled like his cologne, causing my cheeks to burn a slight shade of red that he luckily didn't seem to notice.
"Oh! And this too," Gaege threw a blanket over my shoulders with a small grin. "And I got chocolate in the mini fridge!" He shot up and threw open his fridge, holding up a Hershey's bar with a proud smile, "Want some?"
The way his eyes shined and the smile on his face made me chuckle, and I took the chocolate bar from him with a laugh. "You're the best, you know that?" I told him, wiping away my tears with my thumb. "Thank you so much."
Gaege shrugged, laughing shyly, "It's the least I can do." Gaege looked away with a frown as I began to eat, and I raised an eyebrow.
"Look..." I sighed, taking a bite out of the chocolate bar before continuing, "About what happened back there... I didn't mean to snap at you like that. I'm so sorry."
Gaege shook his head, "It's alright. Really. I knew you were upset about Mully and it's okay-"
"No, not just about Mully," I interrupted before he could continue, "It's about you too. Gaege... I care about you. A lot. More than I even realized."
Gaege was silent for a moment, saying quietly, "Eddie, you know that's not true. It's my fault that Mully is upset and you are fighting anyway."
He rubs a hand over his face with a sigh, his eyes flickering to the open suitcase on the floor. "You're not leaving," I put my hand on his, making his soft eyes meet mine, "I won't let you. I care too much about you to let you leave." His eyes scanned my face, looking for some sort of sincerity in my words. "But I don't want to make things worse," He said quietly, staring into my eyes sadly, "I don't want to be the reason my two best friends fall apart."
I cup his cheek in my hand gently, leaning in closer. His face turned a slight shade of red, but he didn't pull away this time.
"It's okay. It's not your fault," I told him reassuringly, "I'll take care of it. Don't worry." Gaege sniffed, closing his eyes as he took in my touch for a few moments. "I'm sorry Eddie..." He said quietly, putting his hand over mine, "I tried to get over my feelings for you but... I just always seem to come back." I shook my head, rubbing my thumb along his cheek, "It's okay. I understand."
We were silent for a few moments before I brought him in for a tight hug. His soft breath tickled the side of my neck as he buried his head in my shoulder, and I took in his warmth.
He then shifted closer and wrapped his legs around my waist, sitting gently on my lap as his arms wrapped around my neck. It made my heart race uncontrollably, but I didn't push him away. "Gaege..." I started to say, but couldn't help but bring him closer.
We stayed silent for a few minutes, only taking in each other's comfort and embrace. He made me forget about all the troubles I had gone through, and I would've traded anything for another moment with him.
I closed my eyes, taking in his scent and the way his body felt against mine. I gently started to kiss the soft skin of his neck, moving my hands down to grip his small waist. He let out a soft sigh when I slowly moved up to his ear, quietly whispering, "Do you remember when you asked me if I felt the same way you do every time we were together like this?"
He nodded slowly, and I sucked gently on his skin. He sucked in a sharp breath as I left gentle red marks along his collarbone and neck, skimming my teeth against his skin. "Well, I do feel it," I answered, pulling back to meet his eyes, "And I can't get rid of these feelings either, so might as well embrace it." Gaege's hazel eyes flickered away for a moment before saying, "But Eddie... You know what happened the last time we did this. We can't be doing this behind Mully's back."
"But he already knows!" I put my hands on the sides of his cheeks, "And I don't want to think about him right now. I want you, and only you."
Juicy was quiet, contemplating my words carefully. I leaned in slowly, hovering over his lips, questioning what he wanted. He hesitated before kissing me, instantly growing heated the second we touched. Heat bloomed in my chest, making my heart beat a million miles an hour.
He was getting harder in a matter of seconds, grinding his hips in circles on mine. "Fuck, you drive me crazy," I answered, slowly slipping my hands into his pants and over the curve of his ass. He shivered, running his nails down my back. I was hard as a rock now, wanting to devour Gaege entirely.
I pushed him back down on the bed, putting my weight on top of him as I pulled off my shirt. He licked his lips when he saw my body, and I smirked. "Like what you see?" I start to unbuckle my pants, slipping them down, "I think you'll like this even more."
He gulped, slowly taking his clothes off after me. "Oh, you're s-so big," He gaped at my huge cock, "I don't know if..." I tilted his head up with my thumb to see me, planting a kiss on his forehead. "Trust me, it's perfect," I reassured him, "And it will only hurt for a second, okay?"
He nodded, taking a deep breath in as I stretched him out with my fingers.
I slowly pushed myself in, causing him to moan. "Oh fuck!" He put his hand on my chest, wincing as he said, "Ngh, Eddie! It hurts!" I interlock my fingers with his, holding his hands above his head as I continue to push myself in. He let out a strangled moan, clenching his hands into a fist around my hands as I finally stopped for a moment to catch my breath.
"Are you okay?" I asked softly, planting a gentle kiss on his lips, "I'll go slow, okay?" Gaege nodded, taking a shaky breath in, "Be careful... I-I've never done this before."
"Don't worry, just tell me when to stop if you need to," I begin to thrust in and out ever so slowly, feeling Gaege tense up. With my other hand, I held the side of his waist, beginning to move faster.
He moaned, shutting his eyes as his head fell back. "Fuck, I never imagined it to feel so good!" He cries, "Ohh, Eddie! Faster, p-please!" I grip his waist tighter, focusing on going faster and harder. The sound of skin slapping filled the hot room, and I bit my lip, feeling close already.
Gaege cried out when I hit his sensitive area, abusing that spot over and over again. My thrusts became sloppier as I tried to breathe, but I couldn't help but moan softly at how good and warm he was.
"I'm going to-" Gaege moaned out as his body began to shake, growing tighter as he tensed around me. "Oh, fuck you're so tight," I pound into him harder, loving the way he fell apart in front of me.
"Eddie! I..." He stopped halfway through his sentence when I pressed my lips to his, stroking his dick with a hand. He moaned through the kiss, thighs shaking as he came in my hand. I came shortly after, taking in shaky breaths as I tried to regain my bearings.
"I can see why Mully was so upset now," He breathed, putting a hand on his chest, "You know how to pleasure someone holy fuck." I let out an airy laugh, pressing a soft kiss to his forehead.
"You promise you won't leave then?" I asked hopefully, seeing him contemplate my words for a few seconds. "Fine," Gaege answered, "But only if we make it up to Mully. I would hate for him to be upset." I nodded, slowly climbing off Gaege with a moan, "Oh, my back definitely felt that one."
Gaege laughed, "Oh come on, Mexican man. You're getting old."
"Shut up!" I shook my head, grabbing his wrist tightly, "I will pound into you again if I have to." Juicy raised his eyebrows with a teasing smirk, "No one is stopping you..."

A/N: Okay, that was a rly long chapter (1.8K words) pretty proud of myself ngl. Hope you all enjoyed :) thx for the support so far btw and have a good day