She's Mine (Eren x Reader, Reiner x Reader)

Chapter 13~ Him or HIM?

Throwing this huge man off of you just to get your clothes on was the thing that had your heart beating the most. You both scrambled to find your clothes but they were no where to be found.

"Police open up!" Said someone from outside the car.

Shit. You can't believe you actually got caught.

Reiner manages to find his underwear and slip them on then hands you his shirt so you can cover up. He rolls down the window but the look on his face doesn't seem like the look you would give an officer.

"YOU ASSHOLE!" Reiner says pushing the person outside the car.

The person outside cackles. "That's was too funny. Watching you scramble for you clothes."

You can hear the voice for clearly now and you hear that it's Porco.

"I got ya good man. I got ya back." He says still laughing.

"Porco that's not fucking funny!" You yell. "You saw my bare ass!"

"Hey at least it's a good ass." Porco says.

"Get outta here man." Reiner says pushing him again in a more playful way.

Porco leaves and you and Reiner get dressed.

"I'll take you home." Reiner says pulling his shirt over his head.

"No it's okay I think I'm gonna pick stuff up on the way. Uhm. Thank you though." You say hopping out of the car.

You begin to walk away before Reiner shouts, "Hey! Y/n I'm sorry."

"For what?" You giggle.

"For not doing this right." He sighs.

"I'll tell you what. Dinner. Anthonys. Tomorrow. 8. Sound good?" You say pitching the idea for a date.

"Great, I'll see ya then." Reiner says before driving away.

You walk back up the hill and down the street. You hop inside a Dairy Queen for some ice cream. You always get the munchies after sex.

"I'll have a cookies and cream frosty please." You order.

"That'll be $5.99." Says the cashier.

You get ready to hand him some cash but instead a credit card goes over your shoulder and into the hands of the cashier from someone else's hand.

"Double that please." Says a voice from behind you.

You turn around and see Eren standing over your shoulder.

"Wha- what are you doing here this late?" You say.

"Same as you I suppose." Eren says with a smile.

"So you get the munchies after spicy time too?" You question.

"Hell yeah." Eren says.

Was he serious? This dweeb.

"Well here." You say trying to hand him some cash.

"No no. It's on me." He says.

You guys get your ice cream and he checks his watch.

"Nearly sunrise." He says.

"Ah shit. I have class at 7." You say.

"Well too late to catch some sleep now." He says.

He opens his passenger seat door for you. "Hop in."

"Thanks."

He drives you to the bridge that looks out to the river. The sun begins to rise and your ice cream begins to melt.

"So what we're you seriously doing up so late?" You ask licking the ice cream off your spoon.

"Seeing an old friend." He says.

"Don't lie." You say.

"Alright I was hooking up." He says. "I didn't wanna tell you that though. You might get jealous or something."

"Nuh uh! I was getting my own, thank you very much."

"Yeah right. You can't pull like I do."

"Yeah so what are you trying to say?"

"Nothing..."

It falls silent.

"I don't want you to think I'm this big frat boy okay? I'm sorry for getting all over you in the car that day I was drunk but I really like you."

"Wait... what day?"

"Oh.. you must've been too drunk to remember. It was nothing. Never mind."

"Oh... ok."

Then sun has fully risen by now.

"I'll drop you off." He says pulling out with his car.

He drops you off in front of your dorm building. But there's one thing you forgot.

Others could be watching.

Could this become a college scandal?

AN
OK I NEED IMPUT FROM MY READERS
who we rooting for? Eren or Reiner?