She's Mine (Eren x Reader, Reiner x Reader)

Chapter 17 ~ Pain and Suffering

Pulling up to Eren's apartment complex didn't make your nerves feel any better. As Bert's car pulled out of the street and disappeared down the road you've never felt more alone. You give his door a light knock when you reach his apartment door.

"Coming." Eren says groggily behind the door.

He opens the door and is tempted to close it back in your face.

"What do you want?" He asks.

"To make sure you're okay." You answer, trying to be as nice as you can.

"Well I'm fine. You can leave." He tries closing the door back in your face.

"Stop." You say holding the door open.

He lets go of the door and walks to the back of his apartment to the kitchen where he's cooking a grilled cheese. You follow him and shut the door behind you.

"Do you want something?" He asks licking the butter off his fingers after flipping the sandwich over with his hands.

"No I'm okay." You answer.

"Suit yourself." He responds.

Then it's silent for the next couple minutes. You try to make yourself comfortable by taking off your shoes and sitting down but the awkward tension still drifts in the air. Eren scarfs down his sandwich without saying a word to you. He finishes and washes his plate.

"So are you gonna tell me why I have a black eye or are you just gonna sit there like a little innocent bitch as if you weren't pulling at my feelings right now?" He says.

Your stunned by how angry he is. You don't how to respond to that. It offended you but you have no room to make a smart comeback.

"I- I'm sorry." You say quietly.

"Don't be sorry." He says throwing down the towel that he was drying his hands with. "I would do it again if I had to. I just want to know the truth."

"What do you want to know?" You ask.

"How long have you been fucking him?" Eren asks.

"I haven't." You lie.

"Don't lie to me." Eren says grinding through his teeth. "How. Long. Have. You. Been. Fucking. Reiner."

"Not long." You respond. "We've only done it once, it doesn't mean anything."

"Do you know what he did to me?" Eren says in rage.

"I didn't know it mattered." You say back saltily. "I didn't know we were exclusive. Or that picking up my wallet made me venerable to you."

"You knew I was into you, don't play dumb!" He yells.

"He didn't kill your mom." You say back.

Eren looks at you blank. Not knowing what to say.

"Get out." Eren says.

"Make me." You say back.

Eren grabs aggressively by the arm. "I don't want to have to do this."

You grab him by the neck. "I'm a lot stronger than you think."

Eren aggressively slaps the wall behind you.

"I'm giving you one last chance... to leave." He says in your ear.

You don't know what to say or do. Should you leave? No. You can't leave. The more you wait the more tension builds up between you and Eren.

You grab Eren by his belt. "I'm not going anywhere."

Eren's mouth flinches.

"I know you want to kiss me." You say to him.

"Shut up." Eren grabs you by the face and pulls your lips into his. His tongue aggressively forces itself inside your mouth.

His hands run up your shirt and he pulls it over your head. You grab the back of his shirt and pull it off his body. You run your hands down his abdomen.

Eren leads you over to the bed and continues to strip off your clothes. You undo his belt and let his pants fall. The anger you feel turns into craving. After all your clothes are off, Eren guides himself into you. For some reason you feel you've wanted this for a long time. He goes fast and hard, it makes you squirm a bit. You arch up as Eren nibbles on your neck.

Eren keeps this up for a long time. You've been staring at the clock on Eren's desk and it's almost been an hour. You are starting hurt but you still love the adrenaline rush that Eren is giving you.

"Are you gonna cum yet?" You ask Eren impatiently.

"Why you tired?" He says and gives you a look.

"No." You say with a loud swallow.

"Don't worry we are almost there." He flips you over and starts pounding you harder from behind. You bury your face and the sheets to try and hide your moans but he picks ur face up by pulling on your hair. You feel his legs begin to shake and he moves back out of you and finishes on his own. You lay face down on the bed, extremely tired. Eren gets inside his sheets, shuts the light off and goes to bed, completely ignoring your existence, but you are too tired to leave so you just stay where you are and drift off to sleep.

A/N
I AM SO SORRY FOR THE LONG WAIT! I just took my SATs :/.
However, do you ever get that feeling like you shouldn't be writing something? Yeah, I got that feeling with this chapter which is why it took me so long.
But I will write more for you guys, remember to vote Team Reiner or Team Eren. Ngl I'm kinda on team Reiner but some of you want Eren.
And no I'm not making a threesome. 💀
Love you guyssss :). Thanks for reading!