If you haven't watched Sam's video, . You'll need to watch at least part of the game to understand any of this story.
(This was a request. I don't usually write them because for some reason I get really anxious trying to follow someone else's prompt or story-line. I hope it still came out okay and that the anon and the rest of you enjoy it.)
-------------------------------------
After Sam's Paranoia video was finished being filmed, the group revealed a few of the questions that they weren't allowed to share in the video. You had walked into the apartment right after the filming was through and Colby had explained the game to you.
"Mike, do you want to tell Kat what question you voted for her?" Sam smirked, knowing Mike was hoping it would have been forgotten.
"Oh, fuck. Do I have to?" Mike covered his face.
"NOW you do!" Kat laughed.
"Please don't take this the wrong way..." Mike begged. "It was 'who is more likely to have a piercing down where the sun don't shine'"
Kat casually shrugged and let out an "Oh. That's not that bad."
Sam's eyes went wide as he stared at his girlfriend with his mouth hanging open. "We're gonna have a conversation later."
"Someone's a freak!" Tara laughed, the rest of the group joining in.
"I wanna keep playing!" Jake called out, getting up to get another slice of pizza.
"I'm in" Colby agreed. "Grab me a slice!" he told Jake, pulling his feet up on the couch to sit with his legs crossed.
Jake saw you and Colby sitting next to each other, Colby's knee practically in your lap and he started scheming. Jake and Tara were probably your best friends in the group. You had met them right when they started dating and eventually they dragged you into their friend's shenanigans. You had admitted to Tara that you had a thing for Colby and Colby had admitted to Jake that he had a thing for you. Those two told each other everything and therefore...they both knew you liked each other. "Tara, come here." Jake called.
Tara walked into the Kitchen, seeing Jake dawdle by the pizza boxes. "You okay there?" She laughed.
"I need your help" he whispered. "You need to get Y/n to take my spot so I can sit by Colby. I want to fuck with them."
"Ooo, I'm in." She smirked up at Jake, stealing his slice of pizza from him. "How are you going to do it?"
"I'll explain in a minute, but if they're sitting next to each other they can't pick each other as answers so we need to split them up." He explained to her. "Hey guys, I have a rule change." Jake said, walking back into the living room.
"Y/n, come sit by me." Tara grabbed your hand, pulling the two of you to sit between Reggie and Kat
"No more picking out of the hat. The person that would normally pick from the hat gets to make up the question. The coin part stays the same. Heads, you keep the question a secret. Tails, you tell." Jake said, looking to Sam to confirm.
"Makes sense. Then we don't have to write a bunch more questions for the hat. I'm down." He agreed. "Jake, you start."
Jake had sat on the end of the couch next to Colby. He leaned over and whispered, "Who is the most attractive person in the room?"
Colby gave him a shocked look before answering. "I mean, if I'm not allowed to say myself, I have to pick soooomeone." He tried playing it off.
"That could mean so many things." Mike laughed.
