Debt to pay (Hazbin Hotel x Shy reader) (discontinued. Getting rebooted)

Two of us?

Vaggie and Y/N had been dating for a while now, and their relationship was going strong. Y/N was everything Vaggie had ever wanted in a partner; he was kind, caring, and always knew how to make her smile. However, there was someone else who had feelings for Y/N as well - Charlie.

Charlie had been friends with Y/N for a long time and had developed a deep crush on him. She had never acted on her feelings, as she didn't want to jeopardize her friendship with him or Vaggie. However, seeing the two of them together was beginning to weigh on her.

One day, Charlie decided she couldn't keep her feelings bottled up anymore. She sat down with Vaggie and Y/N and told them how she felt. She noticed them going to Vaggie's room earlier. Then she decided to confess to them. She had to confess, before she burst. She walked up the stairs and knocked on the door. Both let her in, and both were almost completely naked.

Y/N and Vaggie sat on the bed together and looked at Charlie. Charlie looked at them both and sighed.

Charlie: Ok. Here we go. Y/N, Vaggie, you've both been such an important people in my life. Y/N. You're kind, caring, and always there for me when I need someone to talk to. You've supported me and helped me out so many times, and I'm so grateful for that. But it's more than just friendship, I...I love you, Y/N. I've had feelings for you for a while now. But then you and Vaggie got together...and...and...

Charlie began crying. Vaggie was surprised to hear this, but she could understand how Charlie felt. She had always known that Charlie had a crush on Y/N, but she didn't realize how deep her feelings ran. Vaggie talked to Charlie, and they both agreed that they didn't want to lose Y/N, but they also didn't want to hurt each other.

After much discussion, they decided to try something unconventional - sharing Y/N. Y/N was hesitant at first, but he loved both Vaggie and Charlie and didn't want to lose either of them. They agreed to give it a try and see how it worked out.

The was a bit awkward for everyone involved. But Y/N was experienced and knew what to do. Y/N would spend time with Vaggie one day and Charlie the next, and they all spent time together as a group as well.

Upon finding out that Y/N would be dating her, Charlie jumped to Y/N and began kissing him repeatedly.