Reincarnated sister

Where did you get that?!

Jack are you ok? Came two voices from behind him. What happened where's Onyx? It was Onyx's sisters. How come you didn't come right back? They asked him. Never mind that he swiped his hand to the side with a shake of his head. Tell me what happened here.

Where are the other guardians? They frowned back at him. In England currently. The other nightmares came. We tried to help stop them but the 3 of us are the odd balls of the family. We're more like our mother. There was nothing we could do. Nightshade shakes her head.

What happened when you left? Have you been watching me? He asked them. From a distance they admitted as Nightshade took the lead. We're your friends and we wanted to protect you and Farrah. Jack told them what happened last he was here.

And then about the voices. How he went to lair eventually because he heard someone calling out to him. And that's when he saw all the teeth canisters. And that while he was digging around Onyx saw him and tried to tell him it was a trap. Though Jack admitted he knew that.

How Pitch got into his head. And that he felt that Pitch was right. No Jack listen to us. She put her hands on his shoulders. Our father is wrong. You're good! What happened here it wasn't your fault. If you had been here there was still nothing you could've done.

One more person wouldn't had made a difference. He told them how Onyx warned him how he tried to protect him Pitch. But that nothing he said was getting through to him. And then next thing he knew he was trapped on the other side showed up here in the Warren.

How he was given his memories and mine. And that Baby Tooth was still there. And that it felt like some kind of secret lair entrance. He felt that if he pushed at the walls they would somehow open. That he heard Pitch's voice and turned and saw what they were looking at now.

Last the guardians all spoke they wanted him to be with them to be one of them. But if he showed up like this he knew they would never listen to him. That they would push him away because he wasn't one of them. Not really just like Pitch said. You have to try Nightshade told him.

We'll go with you. No this is something I need to do on my own. Go back to Farrah's house protect her and her siblings. If that's what you want. Come on Poison she grabbed her little sister's hand. Good luck Jack. She put a hand to his cheek. Thanks I think I'll need it.

The two of them took off back to my house to watch over me and my siblings. And then Jack left to meet up with the other guardians. But he should've know that he was right. When he got there he watched as Bunny tried to interact with the kids. But they couldn't find any of the eggs.

He tried to offer them his new ones but they said they couldn't believe it that there was no such thing as the Easter Bunny. He tried to call out to him his ears drooped. And then they walked right through him a feeling Jack knew a lot about. It's different when the shoe is on the other foot.

When was the last time the guardians weren't believed in? That's when they saw Jack. They asked him where he was. Tooth was worried about Baby Tooth and asked him where he got the teeth containers. They told him what happened after he left. That all the eggs and baskets were crushed.

That nothing made it to the surface. Jack tried to apologize. They knew he had been in Pitch's lair but not anything that happened just that he had his teeth with him and mine from our past lives and that our pictures looked identical. Then Bunny said he had to go.

Jack was heart broken. He couldn't believe what they were saying but he knew they would never listen to him. We never should've trusted you! Your friend Onyx his sisters were there helping when the nightmares came. Where were you?! You were in his lair!

Easter is about new beginnings new life new hope and now it's gone. I'm sorry I never meant for any of this to happen. He tried saying again. But they wouldn't hear it. They turned away from him in disappointment. He had really messed up this time. He just hoped that I was safe.

He turned away as well dropping North's little wooden baby thing into the now frosted over grass. And then he turned back and saw Onyx and his sisters. Jack they called to him. What are you doing here? He asked them. I thought you were at the house?! We went there she's gone!

Gone?! What do you mean gone?! We went to the house Onyx met up with us there but we were too late. No not possible. He shakes his head in worry and in fear. He can't he starts he can't touch her as long as she has her necklace on. Jack? Onyx frowns putting out his hand.

Where did you get this? He asked him as Onyx gave it back to him. It was on the floor of her bedroom. He might not have been able to touch her but a nightmare must've ripped it off her neck and then he must've come for her. I'm sorry Jack. I'm sorry too but I can't help you.

He took his own necklace off. What are you doing? They asked him. The guardians are weak! There's no hope anymore Bunny is going unbelieved in people are having nightmares Farrah could be in danger and I'm not believed in and never will be! I can't even reach out and touch her.

Your father was right about me and so was Bunny. They never should've trusted me I make a mess wherever I go I'm not one of them they dodged a bullet. Jack are you hearing yourself?! Onyx asked him his hands on his shoulders. Snap out of it this isn't you!

Jack brushed his hands off of him pulling away. It is Onyx I've just always tried to be more optimistic in front of others. But when I'm alone this is how I feel. It's how I always feel. I can't do anything right. And I can't stay here. Take these back take hers I don't wanna do something with them I might regret.

He hands Onyx my memory tooth container. Where will you go? He asks him. IDK. He shakes his head. Away. Where no one can get hurt because of me. Somewhere distant and cold and quiet. Goodbye Onyx Nightshade and Poison. And thanks. And then Jack was gone.