The Lost Boys - Imagines and Preferences

If you are a supernatural being, what are you?

David:

You are a vampire like him.
You've been a vampire a lot longer than him though, resulting in you having more knowledge and more power. He likes learning new things from you.

Dwayne:

You're a normal human being. 
If you would ask him to turn you, he'd immediately do it though.

Paul:

You're a normal human being as well.
But Paul really wants you to turn and be a vampire like him so both of you can enjoy eternity together.

Marko:

You are a siren.
That's why your voice bewitched him like that when he first met you.
Being a siren, your voice can make people do what you want them to do. It's kind of like hypnotizing them. They can't remember a thing afterwards.
That's what happened to the boy that stole ice cream for you.

Michael:

You are a normal human being.
When he accidentally got turned into a half-vampire, you immediately helped him trying to find a solution to that.

Star:

You are a vampire.
Dwayne found you and turned you, bringing you to Santa Carla to live with him and the other Lost Boys.

Sam:

Unfortunately, you are a vampire.
You're Marko's younger sister. Both of you used to travel the world until you came here to Santa Carla and Max decided to turn you. Ever since, you are staying here with the other Lost Boys.
You liked being a vampire but when you met Sam, you realized that you would rather spend a mortal life with him, than an immortal one without him.

Since then, you both have been searching for a way to turn you into a normal human being again. After a lot of convincing, Sam was even able to get the Frog Brothers to help too.
At first, they absolutely despised you but after a while they learned to tolerate you (that doesn't mean that they like you though).

Still, when walking out of the comic shop, you occasionally throw glances behind you in case one of them suddenly decided to stake you from behind. One could never be careful enough.

Edgar:

You're a normal human being.
Sam's twin sister actually. You're even older than your brother by ten minutes (you never let him forget that whenever you're bickering over something).

Alan:

He and his brother were fully convinced that you were a vampire for a long time.
To their defense, there were a few kind of suspicious moments with you. Such as you choking on garlic, claiming to hate it with a burning passion, or sleeping a lot during the day and only coming out at night.

You're not a vampire though. You're a completely normal human being.
Proving that to them was very hard though. The Frog Brothers could be quite stubborn (surprising, I know).