Yandere Jonathan Crane x Reader

Joanna finds out about Y/N's relationship with Jonathan

Joanna's POV
I can't believe that my girlfriend's therapist tricked her into a relationship with him. I won't allow it she's mine, but I will tear them apart. I know where Dr. Crane lives because I followed them I saw how he seduced my girlfriend and slept with her, he's taking her away from me, I know she still loves me, it broke my heart when she said that she cries alone at night because of me. I have to admit he's so handsome no wonder my Y/N got her heart stolen, no matter I will make them mine I drive to his house.

Y/N's POV
I woke up early and took a shower after showering I went to the room and Jonathan was still sleeping so I made breakfast a Mexican breakfast of chilaquiles with eggs I needed some ingredients so I quickly rushed to the store got my ingredients and came home and made breakfast I made both red and green chilaquiles I was about to get Jonathan when he came down so I plate the food and we began eating. "This is delicious, my love. The flavors and spices are perfect," says Jonathan with a possessive glint. "I'm glad you enjoyed it, Jonathan. I haven't cooked since Joanna hurt me, and I cooked for her," I say with tears streaming down. "Oh sweetie, forget about Joanna. You are mine forever," says Jonathan, leaning closer and kissing me. We heard a knock on the door so I broke from the kiss and opened the door. I saw my ex-girlfriend and she pushed me inside and came inside too. "Joanna, what are you doing here," I say, looking away from Joanna. "I'm here because I know your relationship with Jonny," says Joanna, looking at Jonathan while touching me. "I will take over for you, baby," says Jonathan, glaring at Joanna.

Jonathan's POV

I can't believe Joanna would come here spy on us and call me Jonny. Only my wife and scarecrow can call me Jonny. She also was touching our Y/N while looking at you. Yeah, I saw that I didn't like it she also ruined my kiss with my girlfriend. "Okay, babe, I love you," my angel says, kissing me softly, pushing Joanna's hands away, and going back to eating. "Joanna, it doesn't matter if we are in a relationship or not it's not your business. Also, please don't call me Jonny," I say, glaring at Joanna with hatred. "She is my girlfriend, Jonathan she belongs to me," says Joanna, looking at my darling sweetly. "I am not your girlfriend Joanna, wait, you slept with Mike again," my love says, getting up in her face and then smelling her. "Um, it's hard to resist. Also, you are sleeping with Jonathan too," says Joanna, looking between us. "Different Sweetheart, I love Jonathan, and you just sleep with different people," my angel says, looking at me with heart eyes. "That's not true. I love you, you're mine," says Joanna, grabbing her close. "Joanna, stop touching my girlfriend, and if you loved her, you wouldn't have cheated on her," I say, moving my darling away from her and going close to Joanna. "Jonathan please understand I didn't mean to sleep with anyone hurting my girlfriend, you see my ex-boyfriend Mike cheated on me, and I loved him so much I felt betrayed until I found her, and I hate myself for being like Mike," says Joanna looking down sadly. "Mike cheated on you. Oh my goodness, I'm sorry," I say, feeling sorry for her. "Yeah, I know I feel terrible," says Joanna, leaning closer to me. Jonny, she's trying to kiss you. What are you talking about, scarecrow? She's grabbing your face, leaning in almost touching your lips. "Wait, woah, what are you doing?" I say, looking at Joanna weirdly. "Nothing," says Joanna, looking down sadly. "Did you try to kiss me," I say, looking at Joanna. "Maybe," says Joanna. "You think it was appropriate because I understood how you feel?" I say, looking at her. "Yes," says Joanna, looking at me sweetly. "No wonder you can't control sleeping with another person. You need therapy, Joanna!" I say, moving away from her. "Ha, welcome to my world!" my angel says, laughing at Joanna. "Haha... right?" says Joanna, trying to do the same thing only about to put her tongue in my love's mouth. "HEY, what are you doing!?" my love says, pushing her away from her. "I-I thought we were going to make out," says Joanna, making circles on my angel's arm. "Oh yeah, you thought!?" says my love. "You thought? THINK THIS!" says my love, slapping her in the face, and Joanna stumbled over. Oh my goodness, this is a funny good job to our girlfriend. Yeah, I think I'm in love with her more. "Unbelievable Joanna unbelievable," says my sweetheart, shaking her head. "Anyway, why are you doing here, Joanna?" I say, trying to compose myself since my girlfriend impressed me by slapping her. "Well, since you asked, can I stay here, please?" says Joanna pleading. "What happened with staying with your brother?" says my love, questioning her. "Well, my dear, my brother's girlfriend is staying, and I don't want to trouble him," says Joanna, answering my girlfriend. Jonny, I don't like it when she calls our girlfriend, "My dear," they aren't together anymore. I know I don't like it either. "What about your lover Mike he can let you stay with him," says my sweetheart, glaring at Joanna. "The thing is that he has a wife, but he says that we belong together and to stop going after you," says Joanna sadly. "Oh, Joanna, I understand how you feel, but don't think that because I understand you can kiss me understand?" I say, looking at Joanna putting boundaries on us. "I swear I didn't mean it. I just find you handsome and hot no wonder you have stolen Y/N's heart, so I thought maybe we could have a poly relationship," says Joanna, pleading. "Joanna you are attractive and beautiful but I don't like you that way I love Y/N ever since she came to me for help, we can be friends and I can help you control sleeping with another person," I say being friendly with Joanna. "N/N, please consider this. we all can be happy forever. You can convince Jonathan in this relationship he would do anything for you," says Joanna, trying to convince my girlfriend. "Jo, calm down. I love you, and I will still love you, but we don't know if this will work. I just want to be friends," says my love, looking at me with love. "Please N/N I know this will work out I won't hurt you again or hurt Jonny I want us happy no more games," says Joanna looking at me sweetly while putting my and my girlfriend's hands in her heart. Jonny, I don't want to be in a relationship with Joanna, just our girlfriend. I know, but if she betrays our trust, it's over, and it's only going to be our girlfriend. "Fine, we can have a poly relationship, but if you cheat on us, it's over. we can't trust you anymore," I say, glaring at Joanna with hatred. "Oh Jonathan, thank you so much. I promise you won't regret it," says Joanna, kissing my cheek. "I do. I don't like this, but what can I say? Jonny's the boss," says my love, not approving this decision but would do anything for me. Jonny, listening to our girlfriend Joanna is not to be trusted. Let's see what happens between us. If she keeps sleeping with random people, then I can't do anything for her. "N/N, please trust me, I won't hurt you. I will prove to you that we can hold this relationship if Jonny gave his approval, then why shouldn't you?" says Joanna, leaning towards her and kissing her. "Fine, let's go eat. The food is getting cold," says my love, going to the table, and we start eating. "Oh wow, sweetie, this is delicious. I remember when you made this but only gave me the red sauce ones because you said the green chilaquiles were yours," says Joanna, tasting our girlfriend's breakfast. "Well, now you have both, and I'm sorry if they aren't like how I used to make them. I haven't cooked since you hurt me," says my love, looking down. "Sweetheart, I'm sorry if I hurt you. I didn't know what I had until I lost it," says Joanna, grabbing our darling's hand. "I guess you did learn your lesson, so maybe this poly relationship will work," says my love, leaning closer to her and closing her eyes while they kiss. "What about my kiss," I say, looking at them. "I will never forget about you, Jonny. I get to kiss you first because we have been together," says my love, kissing me passionately. "My turn and Jonny, I'm great at kissing you won't stop kissing me," says Joanna, grabbing my face and kissing me rough and passionately. She's good but not like our Y/N she only has our hearts. I know she's the only one who can make my heart flutter. "I'm getting jealous, and I don't like this," my love says, smiling sweetly. "Come here sweetheart you know we're a couple now," says Joanna, grabbing her close to us. "I can't say no to this," says my angel, kissing me passionately. "I'm going to my brother's house to get my stuff. I will see you later," says my second girlfriend, kissing us before leaving. "So we agree to be careful around Joanna she's bad and will trap us in her spell," I say, looking at my darling sweetly. "I knew you didn't approve of it, and yes, we won't fall for Joanna," says my love, kissing me passionately. Good Jonny, I knew you wouldn't fail me. Of course, I wouldn't let Joanna convince us. "I love you Jonny thanks for being in my life," says my love, looking at me with love and devotion. We love you too, my dove, and we will protect you from Joanna and anyone who hurts you. That's the sweetest thing you ever said. Tell her that only you but I will meet her soon. "I love you too, my dove, and I will protect you from Joanna and anyone who hurts you," I say, repeating the same words the scarecrow said. Good Jonny, now she won't be able to escape from us. I guarantee she will never leave us. "Oh wow, Jonny, that was the most beautiful thing you have ever said to me," says my love, kissing me passionately, lust showing. I have the urge to make love to her again. Don't hold back, Jonny she wants it too. I won't hold back. I want her now, and I will have her. I carried her to our room and took off our clothes, and made love to her. After making love, we just cuddle each other, enjoying our time together. We get up from the bed and we sat on the couch watching a romantic movie in between the sex scenes I suddenly felt really hot and I wanted to make love to her again she suddenly sits on my lap and kisses me passionately and we make love again this time on the couch. After the movie ends, we just cuddle and kiss more. It was almost 6 pm, and Joanna hasn't come back yet. We don't care about her. We only care about our girlfriends. I know, but we made Joanna our girlfriend too even if we don't like it. Joanna appears after we mention her. "Oh Jonathan, N/N sorry I'm late something happened but everything is fine now," says Joanna, closing the door. "Oh my Jo, what happened who did this to you," says my love, her eyes widening. I changed my mind. We have to protect Joanna too she's ours now. I agree with you. Who could have hurt her like this? "Don't worry about I'm fine. I'm going to take a shower and come back," says my other darling, going to the bathroom. "Wait, Jo, come back and tell us what happened," I say, looking at her bruised face and body. "I will tell you everything after I shower, okay?" says my hurt, darling, going to the bathroom. "Jonny, we have to do something. I can't see her hurt," says my love sadly. "I know my dove, but she needs to tell us what happened," I say, looking at my darling sweetly. Suddenly the bathroom door opens and our girlfriend comes out with bruises and cuts. She looks at us and tells us everything. "That bastard is going to pay," I say, balling my fist. "No, Jonny, Mike will hurt our sweetheart he told me he would rape her and hit her like he did with me. He even killed his wife," says my hurt, darling. "Oh my goodness please Jonny don't let Mike hurt us," says my love, looking scared. We won't let Mike hurt our darling's Jonny go hide them. They are safe, don't worry. "I swear I will protect you both dears, don't worry," I say, leaning towards them and kissing each of them. The door suddenly bursts open, and a guy comes in holding a knife. "I got you now Joanna and sweet Y/N," says the guy going to my woman's. "Mike, please don't do this. I know you aren't like this," says my tainted angel, protecting my angel. "You don't know anything, Joanna, and I was wrong about you. we don't belong together. This sweet angel here does," says Mike, pointing a knife at my angel. "M-Mike, I didn't do anything wrong to you," says my angel, scared of her life. "Oh sweetie, you didn't. You are so pure, unlike Joanna here," says Mike, touching her face with a bloody hand. "Leave my girlfriend alone, Joanna, to your room," I say, defending both my girlfriends. Good Jonny, now make Mike pay. Yes, I will make sure he1 doesn't hurt my girlfriends again. "Baby go with Joanna I love you so much," I say kissing her passionately. "I love you too Jonny please be careful," says my love kissing me back before going to the room Joanna is hiding. "Girlfriend since when is your patient your girlfriend," says Mike glaring at me. "It's none of your business also if you touch her again I will hurt you," I say with gritting teeth. Jonny let me take control for a moment. Fine just for a moment. " Oh Jonathan you don't scare me you can't do anything about it," says Mike threatening me. "Oh Mikey you made a big mistake," scarecrow says controlling my body. "You still don't scare me Jonny even with your deep voice," says Mike trying to look tough. "Oh yeah I show you scared," says my love coming out of the room. Get back in the room darling this isn't your fight," says Scarecrow protecting our wife. "I can help you my love please trust me," says my love pleading with her eyes. We can't say no to her. I know Jonny she's just so darn precious. "Fine sweetheart but if you need help I'm here," says Scarecrow supporting our girlfriend. "You want to see scary I will show you scary," says our girlfriend her eyes glowing red. W-wait w-why a-are y-your e-eyes r-red," says Mike getting really scared. "One thing you don't know about me is I'm immortal, I'm a killer wolf," says our girlfriend glaring at Mike with red eyes. "Now get out before I bite you," says my love her eyes turned back to normal. "Damn that's so hot if I was scared at first now it makes me want you more," says Mike turned on by my darling. "Get out I won't hesitate to bite you," says my hot girlfriend showing her teeth. "I will get you sweetheart and we will be together forever," says Mike looking at my darling with lust. "Get out before I kill you Mike and I won't allow you to come between us," says Scarecrow protecting our wife."Fine but I won't give up on Angel you and I will end up together," says Mike before leaving. "Omg babe that was so hot take me now," says my angel kissing me passionately. As much as I want to make love to her I will let you lead. No, you take the lead, you earned it I'm impressed by your actions today. Thank you Jonny, I won't let you down. We end up making passionate love and she enjoyed Scarecrow's actions she ended up falling asleep. Aww such a sweet angel we need to protect her from Mike. I know she's so hot when threatened Mike today. I know Jonny I can't stop thinking about her red eyes and how she said she's immortal could we be immortal too since we made love to her. I don't know maybe so anyway I haven't heard from Joanna yet after she went to her room I'm going to check on her. Good idea Jonny I hope she's fine. So I went to Joanna's room to find her asleep peacefully. I kissed her lips and went back to my room kiss my angel and went to sleep pulling her close.