Peter Pan Imagines (OUAT)

Prisoners or Lost Girls

Y/n POV:

'Why? Why am I in a stupid cage?!' I yelled in my head as I shook the cage.

"Y/n! Shaking the cage is not going to help!" Wendy yelled so I could hear her since we were about 50 feet apart.

"Do you have a better idea to get out of these stupid cages?" I yell back.

"No, but you have been shaking the cage every minute." She yells.

I groan. I know shaking the cage wouldn't help but I didn't know what else to do. I got us into this mess.......

"You didn't get us into this mess." Wendy yelled at me. 

'I swear I think she is hiding that she can read my brain.'

"Yes, I did Wendy!" I yelled louder than I needed to.

"No, you didn't." 

"Wendy, if it wasn't for me standing up to 'Peter Pan' we wouldn't be in these cages." 

"You were just trying to protect me. I love that about you. I am glad you did or else Pan could make us his puppets."

I laughed. "You're right."

"Aren't I always."

I couldn't help but laugh again.

"You know. Your laugh is actually beautiful." I turn my head to see Peter Pan leaning against a tree.

"Yeah, right. Stop trying to seduce me because it ain't gonna work." I folded my arms across my chest.

Peter Pan chuckled. "Not all women are like this, are they?"

"Like what?" I was genuinely confused.

"Feisty, courageous, protective, hardworking because that is definitely what you are and I have never met another woman like you." 

'Don't let him get into your head, Y/n. He is just saying those things to get to you and make you one of his puppets.' I said to myself in my brain.

I didn't change my facial expression at all.

"You really are feisty." Peter Pan walked over to my cage and squatted down. "I want to make you a deal."

"No, thanks." I bluntly said.

"I suggest you listen, Y/n, because I don't give people second chances."

"That makes a lot of sense with you." I stated truthfully.

"Do you want to hear my deal or not?" Peter Pan raised an eyebrow at me. "Oh, and before you answer 'no' I will let you know, it has something to do with your sister, Wendy."

I looked at him dead in the eyes. "If you hurt Wendy I will kill you."

"I won't hurt Wendy if you make the right choice. Believe me. I am a man of my word." I could tell he answered truthfully.

"Fine. What is your deal, Pan?" He couldn't help but smile.

"You have two choices. Either Wendy gets severely hurt and you die or you become My Lost Girl and Wendy can either go home or stay here depending on what she wants. The choice is yours."

"So what you're saying is: You and Wendy both die or you both get to live under my command." I wanted to make sure I understood while mimicking his voice.

"The first part, yes, the second part you got wrong. YOU would live under my command and Wendy can choose to go home or stay." I could tell he was ignoring that I mimicked him.

I look over to Wendy who was still in the cage. She was watching us probably trying to figure out what Peter Pan was saying to me. I couldn't let them hurt her or worse, kill her.

"Okay. I will become your Lost Girl but you have to promise me that you won't hurt Wendy no matter what." I was stern.

"Then you have a deal." 

Pan put his hand in the cage and I shook it.

That was the closing of our deal.

"Y/n! You did not just make a deal with Peter Pan!" Wendy yelled.

"It seems like she did, Wendy." Pan said calmly.

Pan then opened the door to my cage. I gave him a confused look.

"You are now My Lost Girl. I am not going to keep you in a cage."

He held out his hand for me to take but, instead, I get out myself without taking his hand.

 I stood up next to him. "What about Wendy?"

"Don't worry. I will let you let her out but she has to make the choice right now and she can't change it once it is made." Pan folded his arms on his chest.

I run over to Wendy's cage while Pan stayed where he was standing.

"Y/n, what deal did you make with him?" Wendy asked as I was unlocking the door to the cage.

"It was a really easy deal to make. Either we died or we lived." I informed her as I swung the cage open.

"What is the catch?" She said as she got out of the cage.

"I have to stay here for the rest of my life an-"

"What?!" Wendy yelled, interrupting me.

"You can go home thought." I quickly got out.

"No, no, no. What? Y/n, are you serious? Why? No! I won't leave you."

"It is okay. You can go home to Mom and Dad and our brothers. You can go back home." I explained.

"No, you are my home. You are my twin sister. I can't loose you." Tears were forming in her eyes.

"But Wendy-"

"No! I am staying here."

As Wendy said this, she hugged me. "I won't loose you." She whispered in my ear.

I hugged her back. "You won't loose me."

"I made up my mind. I will stay here with you, even if it means forever."

I knew I wasn't going to be able to change her mind. We were the same in this way. Once our mind was made up no one can change it.

"Okay. It is your choice." 

We pull away from the hug.

"We are in this together." Wendy said giving me a look I have seen so many times.

I nod my head. "Together." 

I know this is more like a Wendy imagine but I made sure to add Peter falling for you.

I hope you enjoyed it!

Requests are open! 

Have an amazing day! Love you!