Creepy pasta one shots

Toby's secret

You and Toby have been dating for almost two years now, but you always felt like he was always at work or making excuses on why he couldn't spend time with you. Toby would always do this on date nights, he would be there during the day but as soon as it's dark out he has to cancel because work called or his friend needed help.

One day you were tired of Toby constantly canceling on your dates and staying out really late, He left the house after another expected "work" call, yeah right. you closely followed behind him, he didn't take his car which was weird but it just made you even more upset at him. You had been following him into the forest, you were a distance away and Toby kept looking at his phone which made you feel a dreadful feeling in the pit of your stomach, what if he was cheating? What if he was meeting some woman out here while you were supposed to be at home blissfully unaware.

Toby had eventually stopped walking and you hid behind a tree a few meters away, you were so close to tearing Toby apart for cheating but you held yourself back, because of curiosity of course.

For about almost 30 minutes he was leaning against a tree and checking his phone. until a woman he was presumably waiting for showed up, and she was beautiful. Like the girl everyone either wanted to be or be with. She waved to Toby before placing her hands on his shoulders and kissing him, Toby seemed to have a sickened expression on his face by her touch.

Toby had talked with her for a few minutes before rolling his eyes with a bored expression on his face. Then Toby smiled creepily before hitting her with a hatchet in the arm. she screamed loudly and Toby had struck her again in the chest, She fell down and Toby just kept hitting her. You covered your mouth with your hands in shock, you were surprised to say the least, but you were glad he wasn't cheating, yet you despised the fact you found something good about the entire situation.

Toby had stood above her dead corpse, it seemed like he was admiring his work. You felt sick to the stomach but you had a creepy excitement towards this revelation, he was killing woman instead of sleeping with them. You felt a tiny smile creep on your face, by the time you realized this Toby was walking away from her body and towards you. Toby hadn't seen you, then you hid behind a tree trying to avoid him catching you. You had to find a way to quietly get ahead of him to run back home and appear like you never left.

You quickly and quietly sift through the trees to make your way home before Toby could see you weren't at home. You arrived home just mere minutes before Toby did, you were completely out of breath sitting on the couch. Toby walked over to you and lightly kissed you on the forehead. His clothes were lightly stained with blood, Toby walked upstairs and got into the shower. You sat and waited for him to return, while you were sitting on the couch a revelation suddenly came to you. It sounded odd and psychotic, but you decided to not call the police on Toby.

Toby walked down the stairs with a small smile on his face, he wasn't wearing a shirt just pants. he was clean and there was no trace of blood anywhere. You stared at him for a long while, Toby smirked as you looked at his body closely. He wrapped his arm around you as toby finally was spending time with you although it was late. You turned on a show on the tv and watched it together until you both fell asleep.