The Soulmate Game (REVERSE HAREM X READER)

Chapter 12 - Beg for It

After discarding the used condom in the trash, Hiroto protectively wrapped the bed sheets around my naked and vulnerable form. "How are you feeling? That probably wasn't what you imagined your first time to be like, right...?" He asked with guilt present in his voice.

I suppose he was right. That wasn't exactly what I envisioned. But not because it was a horrible experience. On the contrary, Hiroto did everything in his power to make it as comfortable as possible. So if anything, I had no complaints about the ordeal. Hiroto was a very attentive partner.

"I'm sorry for taking it away from you–" Before Hiroto could continue to wail in blame, I softly pushed his ginger hair back to try and comfort him.

"I... didn't hate it. In fact, I was glad my first time was with someone like you." Embarrassed, I pushed my hair behind my ears before diverting my gaze from him. "You made me feel so special and safe... So thank you for that."

Hiroto's mouth morphed into a 'o' shape as his eyes widened in shock. Trying to play it off and act cool, he quickly coughed into his hand to try and brush off his nerves. "Is that so? Well, I'm glad I was able to at least make you feel somewhat at ease, (Y/N)-chan!"

I chuckled at Hiroto's silliness as the tension in my body completely evaporated. "You really don't have to treat me so special, Hiroto. I'm not a fragile girl, nor will I bite you. So drop the formalities and treat me like you would anyone else! I feel like we've long moved passed the honorifics at this point anyway, right?"

Hiroto gave a light nod before playfully adjusting the bedsheets so they were now wrapped snuggly around my shoulders and neck as if I were one gigantic blob. "Alright, then we can start by having you call me Hiro." He bantered.

"You got it, Hiro~" I teased in a flirting voice. Hiroto smirked before buttoning his shirt the rest of the way up.

"Feels like we're closer already, (Y/N)~" He joked back.

As Hiroto made his way towards the door, he paused before tightly gripping the frame. He seemed... antsy.

"I really did mean what I said earlier." He started in a serious tone. "You're in one of the worst positions here. So I'll do whatever I can to help you make the best of things." He turned to give me one last sad smile before leaving. "So if any of the others try to pressure you into doing something you're uncomfortable with, let me know. I'll try to straighten them out for you!"

In response to Hiroto's heroic declaration, a noticeable crimson glow was painted across my face. Embarrassed, I burrowed my head into the bedsheets. There was just something about his caring disposition that made my heart flutter uncontrollably like a child experiencing their first school crush.

So when the time came for the door to open once more, I was caught completely off guard. Confused, I looked around before furrowing a questioning brow. "Huh...?" I grumbled to myself.

"You seem surprised to see me," Seiji affirmed as he strolled inside the room with crossed arms. As he stood there with a haughty attitude, dread soon crept up over me.

"Oh. It's you... I completely forgot you were still here..." I answered with evident disappointment.

Seiji shook his head before clicking his tongue and drawing closer to me. "We all have to participate in this challenge. So you shouldn't be surprised that it's finally my turn."

As I listened carefully to his words, I found myself perplexed by what exactly his turn would entail. "Wait. I've pretty much completed every other base and had sex. So what else is there even to do...?"

A sadistic grin soon grew across his face as Seiji forcefully cupped my chin. "I wouldn't be so sure about that if I were you. There's still one thing you haven't done yet." I narrowed my eyes as I listened to Seiji continue. "Like anal~"