A Beautiful Tragedy

The engagement

One day before the anniversary

Emily's POV
Hanna and I have it all planned out, tomorrow I'm going to take Ali out for an expensive dinner than I'm going to take her home and propose on Hanna's " romantic rose petals". Oh my fuck, I'm so nervous though.

Alison's POV
Tomorrow everything is going to change, while Emily and I are out at dinner I'm going to propose and I really hope that she says yes because without her I'm nothing and it will kill me if she says no.

Aria's POV
My conversation with Emily sucked, why can't she see that I really am sorry? God why does she have to be so selfish and only think about herself and her family? Doesn't she remember that once I was apart of her so called " family". Yeah sure I messed up but everyone makes mistakes right? You know I should've never wasted my time on trying to get Emily's approval, I'm just going to tell Spencer straight up that I fucking love her and that I know that I hurt her but I deserve another chance. I hopped into my car and drove to Spencer's apartment, determined to get back what's mine. When I arrived I took a deep breath and knocked on the door, about a minute later she opened the door with a huge smile on her face but when she saw me it dropped " wow for a second there I thought you were happy to see me" she glared at me and said " who the fuck allowed you into my building?" I have to admit her words hurt at first but I shook it off " that doesn't matter, can I come in?" I asked " no, Ali maybe coming over soon" she told me, when she was about to close her door I stuck my foot out and said" oh really, I actually just talked to Alison and Emily" confusion was written all over her face " they were actually really mean to me" she gave me a blunt look " and I should care because?" Oh god if I don't step up my game she's never going to talk to me, think of a lie Aria " well Alison said some pretty mean things about you too, like how your life was falling apart and how you can be a bitch" I lied, she put her head down in disappointment " please Spencer, let me explain everything. Please give me another chance I promise I won't fuck up this time" I begged, she slowly opened her door and let me in. Great plan Aria, now it's time to get your girl back.

Alison's POV
After dinner Emily fell asleep so I took that as my opportunity to leave for Spencer's but right before I left I got a text from her saying that I couldn't come anymore because she wasn't feeling well and just wanted to sleep. Huh that's weird.

Anniversary day

Aria's POV
I woke up naked and my head was on Spencer's chest. Last night was a good fucking night. I felt Spencer start to stir so i pecked her on her lips " good morning gorgeous" she looked at me confused for a second then it hit her " oh good morning Aria" I got up and got changed into the clothes I was wearing yesterday " want breakfast?" I asked, she nodded and lied back down. I walked into Spencer's tiny kitchen and saw her phone blinking, I opened it and noticed it was a text from Alison:
Oh okay, I hope you feel better soon. Want me to come check up on you?
Spencer never replied to her so I decided to for her:
Hey come over this morning and we can talk if you want?
I hit send and she immediately replied:
Sure! We can finish planning the proposal :) I'll be over around eleven
I sent back a quick okay and put Spencer's phone in her purse, I started making coffee when Spencer walked out in a robe and slippers " I'm making coffee spence" she walked over to me and wrapped her arms around my waist " that's great, thank you."

Emily's POV
After our eventful morning, Hanna, Ali, and I decided to watch movies till it was time for Ali and I to start getting ready for dinner. I got ready in our guest room because I really wanted to surprise Ali, I was wearing a red floor length dress that showed off some cleavage but not to much. It was classy but very sassy, Hanna told me that I suck at doing my hair so she was going to do it. She straightened my hair then put it in a ponytail but left my bangs out and for make up, well I like simple so I put on some mascara and red lipstick. I slid on a gold bracelet and put my black heels on, I walked in front of the floor length mirror and looked at myself " damn Emily, you look good" Hanna smirked " are you sure she's going to like it?" I asked suddenly feeling self conscious " Emmy she's going to love it because if I wasn't straight and been best friends with you since we were little I would totally do you" I gave myself one last look and walked out. When I came out I saw Ali sitting on the couch, she looked gorgeous. She was wearing a white dress that stopped about mid thigh and paired it with a black leather belt and nude coloured heels. It looked absolutely perfect. she must've heard the sound of my heels because when she looked up at me her jaw dropped " I'm guessing I look okay" she nodded her head up and down then said " you look sexy baby, I can't wait to get you out of that dress though" she hit my ass and smirked. I hear Hanna clear her throat and both Ali and I turn to see what her problem was " Alison I expect my baby girl to be home by eleven and if she's not you do now want to know what the punishment you will get" I laughed at how protective Hanna was being but Ali looked terrified " don't worry baby, she's just joking" I whispered in Ali's ear, she calmed down a little bit I could tell she was still a little scared " ready to go" Ali asked " yup let me just get my purse" Hanna walked up to me and started kissing my cheeks and hugging me " awe my baby's growing up so fast" she fake cried, I heard Ali laughing behind her and a small giggle escaped my mouth. I turned away out of Hanna's grasp and dragged Ali out the door " goodbye mother!" I yelled " don't forget a condom Ali!" She screamed before I closed the door.

We arrived at Ali and I's favourite restaurant and we both walked in hand in hand. When we got in I noticed it wasn't really busy which was nice, the hostess looked at me to see what I was going to say " hi, two for fields" she nodded her head and said " it's nice to see you again Emily" I looked at Ali and she was glaring at the back of the hostesses head, I squeezed her hand and pecked her cheek. When we got to our table I pulled the chair out for Ali and when she sat down and got comfy I passionately kissed her than sat down myself " how did I ever get so lucky?" Ali asked " I think the better question is how did I get so lucky" she laughed at my response.

Halfway through the dinner I noticed Ali started fidgeting and kept looking down at her lap, I told her that I had to go to the washroom and when I walked past her I noticed she was playing with a ring. I walked into the washroom and put cold water on my face and that's when it hit me, oh my god Ali is about to propose! I started dancing around in excitement but what about my plans? I could just make my plans happen a little faster, I called Hanna and told her that Ali and I were leaving early because I wanted to propose first. She kept telling me that she wasn't ready but I told her to work faster than hung up, I walked back to the table and saw that Ali put the ring away " hey baby I'm not feeling well can we go home?" She looked disappointed and concerned " oh okay are you going to be alright?" I nodded than put money on the table, Ali got up and intwined our hands. She gave me a small squeeze and we left. The car ride was silent but when we were about twenty minutes away from home we heard a loud popping noise " what the fuck was that Em?" Ali asked surprised " I think a tire burst" I pulled over and got out of the car, Ali came out with me " babe can you get the spare tire in the back please" I asked " um okay?" She rolled the tire back over to me, I was kneeling on the ground looking at the tire hoping that it would fix itself " where do you want it Em?" " you can drop it right there" I mumbled focused on the tire and also hoping that Hanna was done. When Ali put the tire down she kneeled beside me and looked at me " do you know how to fix it?" I shook my head, I made eye contact with Ali and just stared at her and I knew exactly what she was asking me because she gave me that look and I knew that she knew what I was asking because at the exact same time we both whispered " yes."