The Neighbour

The Neighbour Chapter 16

Madison's POV
I woke up the next morning to pounding in my head. It took me ten minutes to convince my eyes to open. The drunken haze of sleepiness and giggles was long gone. And in its place was the worlds worst headache. I groaned to myself as I sat up, unwrapping Hayes' arms from me. Wait, where the hell am I? Suddenly a few of last nights events came flooding back into my mind. I looked down at Hayes, who was still fast asleep. Oh. my. fucking. god. I had sex with Hayes last night. Its not like I regret anything about it, from what I remember it was amazing. What about Nash. I had a really good thing going on with him. Well that was until he walked in on Hayes and I. Throughout the whole night I was with Hayes. It was his fault for leaving me with his brother who I once had a thing with and still do. He told me he was coming back which 2 hours later clearly proved he wasn't. And really its not like I was Nash's girlfriend. I was about to walk out of the door until I realized I was still butt naked. I grabbed my clothes and quickly threw them on. I grabbed my phone off the dresser beside the bed and walked out. My house wasn't far from the Jack's so I figured I would let everyone sleep and just walk. On my way out I texted Hayes saying "Hey baby, I had to leave but hope to see you soon. Thanks for the amazing night. Xoxo -M". I was about to walk out the door until someone grabbed my wrist. I quickly turned my head to see who it was. "Nash?" I said scared to death. He pulls me outside and closes the door behind us. "What the fuck were you thinking Madison?" He yells while looking in my eyes "What do you mean?" I said acting dumb which was a stupid thing to do. "You know exactly what I mean! You fucking my brother" "Nash I was drunk. My mind was full of alcohol, I didn't know what I was doing" which was true but I don't regret one bit of the night. "Do you have feelings for him?" He asks out of the blue. "Nash" I say while sighing. "MADISON DO YOU HAVE FEELINGS FOR HIM" he yells while grabbing my shoulders intensely with anger written all over his face. "YES. Yes Nash, I have feeling for Hayes" He lets go of my shoulders and  backs up while stuffing his face in his hands. "But I also have feelings for you Nash" I say with a tears falling down my face. Nash looks up and stares deeply into my eyes. "Madison you can't do this. You can't have feelings for the both of us. Its me or him" "Nash, I don't know" I say with a crack in my voice from crying. "CHOOSE" he yelled. He had tears dripping down his face like a waterfall, nonstop. His eyes were bloodshot red and he constantly snuffled from his nose being stuffed. "I CANT FUCKING CHOOSE, I LOVE YOU BOTH" I screamed at him causing both of us to cry even more "You loved me?" He asked taking a step closer to me "Nash I still do" I mumbled taking a step closer to him "No Madison, you can only have feelings for one of us. Im not playing games. Im not your fucking toy you can't just play with me when the other doesn't want to. Im not you fucking second choice. I'm giving you the rest of the day to make your decision, Ill Inform Hayes about this. At 10pm ill be waiting at home and Hayes will be here at Jacks. If you choose me, you simply come over to my house. But on the other hand, if you choose Hayes, you come here. Bye Madison." He said walking back in the house slamming the door behind him. I instantly broke down. I fell to the ground on my knees and tucked my body into my knees. I realized how bad this was and knew I had to make a decision. But who?