Ponyboy- a locket necklace with a picture of you two inside
Johnny- a jean jacket (so you two could be matching ☺️)
Sodapop- a giant teddy bear along with a bouquet of roses
Steve- a box of chocolates and some flowers
Two-bit- A Mickey Mouse sweatshirt and a card
Dally- He takes you to get matching tattoos 💞
Darry- a pair of diamond earrings
