Chapter Three: First Date

24 4 2
                                    

"I l-love you." Toby says to me as we lay down cuddling up in his bed watching T.V.

"I love you too." I say back as I cuddle with his arm wrapped around me.

All the sudden as we are laying down someone knocks on his door causing us to both just a little. We both sit up on his bed as Toby yells come in. It was just L.J. 

"Well you two have been hanging out quite a bit lately, do you guys have a thing for each other or something?" He asked.

"N-no, we're j-just friends. is th-that so bad?" Toby says covering for both of us.

"No, just weird I guess, sorry for asking. I was just gonna tell you that we might be going on a killing spree and we were wondering if you guys would want to come?"

"Oh, s-sure." 

"Cool, we are leaving at two o'clock. Meet us downstairs." He says walking away closing the door behind him.

I look over at the black clock hanging up on Toby's wall, 1:23 a.m. 

"I'm gonna go get read I guess, I love you." I say standing up form his bed.

"Alright, I-I love you too." He says as we kiss each other for a few seconds.

I walk out of his room and down the hallway into mine. I put on my holster with my axe in it like always and put my belt on with my hatchet holster on it along with my hatchet. I walk back out of my room and go downstairs to see L.J. and Jeff. Then Toby comes running down the stairs to join us.

"Everyone ready?" L.J. asked everyone.

Everyone agreed with him and we all ran out into the woods. Most of us separated except for me an Toby. We decided to murder together, it was his decision. We were just testing it out to see if we like murdering together. 

~Time Skip: Two Hours Later~

We all run back to the mansion covered in blood, dirt, and sweat.

"I got shower first!" I yell as I run into my room throwing my holsters and weapons into the closet then running into the bathroom closing the door.

I take off my clothing and turn the shower on. I get into the shower as the water mixes with the blood, dirt, and sweat dripping down to the floor and into the drain. I wash my hair and my body then get out after doing so. I grab the towel and dry myself then wrap it around my waist and walk out of the bathroom. As I start to walk over to my room Toby walks upstairs to see me almost fully naked causing us to both blush.

"Oh, s-sorry." He says.

"Oh, it's ok. You would see me like this sooner or later." I say.

"Wait, I didn't mean to say that!" I say quickly after realizing how wrong that sounds.

"No, i-it's ok. C-calm down." He says giggling.

I just nod my head and quickly run to my room and closing my door shut almost slamming it making me jump a little. I walk over to my dresser and take out a pain of black shorts and a dark green tank-top. I take my towel off letting it drop to the floor and put on my clothes that I just got out.

I go and sit down when someone quickly walks into my room closing the door, I look up to see it is just Toby. I go and sit down on my bed as he looks over at me.

"H-hey, follow me, I-I have a place to show you!" He said then quickly opened the window and jumped out.

I run over to the window and jump out following him. After about twenty minutes or so he stopped in front of a very covered wall of trees, leaves, and branches.

"Ok, put th-this on." He says throwing a green bandanna at me.

I put it on making sure it is covering my eyes. Then I feel Toby's hand grab mine and start to pull me forward. I feel the leaves and branches brush against me as he continues to pull me.

"Now t-take it off." He said letting go of my arm.

I do as he says taking off the bandanna revealing my eyes once again. I look around as my eyes widen in amazement seeing the beautiful valley full of blood red roses and Fireflies glowing gold.

"It's beautiful!" I say in amazement.

 "I-I know right, h-here!" He said and then ran over to a blanket laid out with a picnic basket on one corner of it.

he goes and sits down as I follow him down.

"Did you do all of this?"

"Y-yep, do y-you like?"

"Yes, I love it!"

he grabs the basket and opens it handing me some food. About an hour later of eating, talking, and laying down holding hands and looking up at the midnight sky.

We walk back to the mansion once the sun was starting to rise.

"Oh, and where have you two been all night?" Slenderman asked as we both walked into the mansion.

"Oh, u-um-" Toby starts to say then stopping because he most likely can't think of anything.

"We were just killin-"

"Don't, child, come meet me in the office in five minutes. We need to talk." He said then teleporting to most likely to his office.

"Toby, he knows!" I quickly say once he left.

"How d-do you know?"

"It was obvious."

We both start to walk towards his office and opening the door and closing it behind us.

"Sit." He says sitting at his desk and we do so.

"Ok, if your gonna have a relationship then then you have to at least tell me. We need to talk about it." He says as Toby's eyes widen.

It didn't really surprise me. I knew that someone would have cough onto it. We were being kind of obvious about it. Hanging out all the time, keeping something hidden.

Wait, he's not gonna tell the rest of the Creepypasta, is he?

Jake the Lumberjack: The ReturnWhere stories live. Discover now