A Creepypasta Love Tangle

Chapter 2: They're Real?

A/N: I am amazed. I didnt think anybody would add this to their Reading List! Thanks you guys, it's great to know someone's reading. 😁

Focus: Scarlett

Scarlett felt something brush against her face. She twisted around and saw her twin sister, Zielly, staring at her.

"Mmf... Zielly...?" She said, tired and stretching. Zielly immediately clapped her hand over Scarlett's mouth and shushed her.

She motioned to Scarlett to turn her head. She did so. And there they were. Every last creepypasta she'd heard of.

Instead of screaming, she clung onto Zielly for dear life, breathing heavily. Zielly clung back, scared out of her wits.

Only then did Scarlett get a good look of the room. They were in a luscious four-poster bed with silky red covers and curtains. Right beside the bed there was a small red rug with golden trimmings. Black tiles lined the floor, and windows facing the bed showed it was midnight. The windows also had red curtains with golden trimmings. Huge black dressers were on either side of the room, one of them decorated with small creepypasta dolls. The other was decorated as well.

But, there was something wrong about the decorations.

There were two dolls.

Hugging each other. One wore a silky red dress that was sleeveless and the tiniest bit loose. It had bright red high heels. The other one wore a black puffy dress that was short and had spaghetti straps. It had stockings and black heels too.

Those two dolls look familiar.

They both had long black hair with brown stripes or ends.

They both had a caramel-milk chocolate skin.

They both had one green eye and one eye that changed color every now and then.

They were twins.

They looked just like Zielly and Scarlett.

"What the heck? Who made those?! How'd they get here?!" Scarlett thought.

The man with the white face chuckled. "Do not trouble yourself, child. Those are merely dolls made by Sally. She needed some new ones."

A small girl came out of the shadows. She wore a pink nightgown and carried a teddy bear with her. She had long brown hair and beautiful green eyes. She could've been a young girl minding her own biswax if she wasn't covered in blood.

"Hi." She smiled sweetly.

Scarlett was too scared to smile back. All of the creepypastas seemed to stare at Scarlett and Zielly.

Focus: Zielly

They were staring at her. She was really uncomfortable, and clung to Scarlett a little harder, who didn't seem to notice.

Zielly slowly moved away from Scarlett and got out of the bed. She walked directly to Slender. Scarlett looked at her with a panicked look, but Zielly continued. Panic and fear turned her hazel eye a royal blue, but she politely asked him a question.

She took a deep breath.

"M-Mr. Slender?" She asked, her fingers trembled as she looked at his faceless head.

"Do not worry, child, we will leave." Slender seemed to have read her mind. "And, please, call me Slender."

He beckoned to the others. They left. Eyeless Jack took one last look at Scarlett and then left. BEN stared at Zielly and smiled at her. Then he left.

"Z-Zielly! You're wearing the black dress the doll is wearing...!"

"Calm down, Scarlett. Trust me. You'll get used to them. If Slender takes you in, he knows you're pure of heart. We stay."

"THEY'RE REAL! THEY'RE NOT SUPPOSED TO BE REAL!!!"

"Please calm down. I promise you'll love them. Just give me a chance."

"O-ok. Alright. Ok." Scarlett took a deep breath. "Ok."

"I'll... leave you to your thoughts..." Zielly left the room, going downstairs. She hoped she'd find her way around here.

After wandering for a while, she bumped into a floating kid with no arms, nor legs. Instead, there was blood. Blood stained the sleeves of his jacket. It indicated that his arms had been ripped off. His shorts looked the same.

His face was pale, almost snow white. His eyes were cold black depths with red pupils flowing in the middle. He had short black hair and wore a cap over it. He wore it backwards so that a tuft of hair would fit through the hole in the back.

Overall, he was cold, but had a great warmth about him. Strange. It brought a blush to Zielly's cheeks. She wondered why.

"H-Hi..." Zielly said greeting the boy.

"H-Hi, Z-Ziel-lly."

"Y-You know my name?"

"Yes... I-I thi-ink the w-whole m-mans-s-sion knows your n-name."

"Oh... anyway, I need to ask you a question."

"Y-yes?"

"How do you find your way around here?"

"Oh, t-that's ea-easy. N-no w-wor-worries."

Zielly blushed madly. "He doesn't seem too bad..."

BEN watched with jealousy.

Focus: Scarlett

Scarlett was pondering how she would cope with everything when she heard a knock.

"Zielly?"

"No... Sorry."

A male voice floated through the door. It was almost soothing, it sounded sweet.

"C-Come on in, I g-guess..."

The same boy with the blue mask  came in. He wore a black sweatshirt with torn jeans. The blue mask had eyeholes that leaked black ooze. He came over to her as she sat on the bed.

"Is everything okay?"

"Yeah, I-I'm fine."

"You sure?"

He brought his face closer to Scarlett. She blushed like crazy.

"U-Um..."

"Oh, sorry." He withdrew his face, obviously embarrassed.

Jeff was just by the door, waiting for another kill.

A/N: What'd you think? Definitely recommend this story, even if only two people are reading. Enjoy. BTW, I probably won't update during the week, with it getting close to testing and stuff. But, expect me to update during the weekend! I promise you guys I won't let you down. I've never gone back on a promise. Trust me. Anyways, Chapter 3 is coming soon, possibly later today. Please enjoy. I'll see you later! 😊