A Creepypasta Love Tangle

Chapter 3: Building Blocks of...

A/N: Goodness, 16 readers! Gosh, I never expected to get this far in only two days! Thanks for reading, even if you don't enjoy it. At least people look at it. By the way, don't forget to vote of you do like it! If we get up to 10 votes, I just might add a little "Secret Side Story" for your enjoyment. Lemme know in the comments who the side story should be about. I'll have a poll at the bottom. Anyways, please enjoy this next chapter, Chapter 3! 😊

Focus: Zielly

"Thanks for showing me around here, Lost Silver!"

"Y-You're w-we-welcome, Z-Zie-lly." Silver smiled a cute smile.

Zielly smiled back and said goodbye to Silver. Zielly had gotten to know Lost Silver along the tour of the mansion. Scarlett immediately popped in her head.

"I wonder if she's ok now..."

Zielly rushed back to their room to check on Scarlett, who probably hadn't calmed down yet.

Right when she was on the stairs, however, she bumped into someone...again...

"Gah!" The boy yelled as he fell backwards.

"S-Sorry..." Zielly stuttered. This boy was different. He looked almost like Link from Legend of Zelda, Zielly had seen them on posterboards before.

He had deep black sockets with a small red pupil glowing in the middle, just like Lost Silver did. He also had blood leaking from his eyes.

He had beautiful blonde hair and a green costume like Link's. That's when Zielly realized it was the same boy who stared at her before he left.

"It's okay..." The boy suddenly spoke, shaking Zielly from her thoughts.

Zielly helped him up and stared at his pupils. He stared back.

"Why do they look like that?" Zielly thought.

"What's wrong? The boy suddenly asked. His cheeks were dusted with the color pink.

Zielly was embarrassed, making her hazel eye turn green.

"N-Nothing! Sorry. I was just wondering why they look like that."

"They?" The boy asked, obviously confused.

"Your eyes." Zielly said. She got up on the tips of her toes to look closer. "Why are they like that, if you know?"

Ben's cheeks turned bright red.

Focus: Scarlett

Eyeless Jack and Scarlett had only managed to make small talk so far. It was soothing to Scarlett. His mere presence seemed to cheer her up. She wondered why. Whenever she talked to him, her hazel eye turned pink.

"Why is your eye pink?" Eyeless Jack asked.

"I-I don't know..." Scarlett said. Half of her lied. The other half truly didn't know.

As they made more small talk, Jeff listened by the door. He smiled to himself.

Scarlett excused herself for a bathroom break. She walked towards the door. Jeff waited for her as she walked. He covered her mouth and pushed her against the wall.

Scarlett's hazel eye turned black as she stared at Jeff.

"Aren't you an interesting specimen..." Jeff said, staring at her. Scarlett was too scared to scream. She breathed heavily.

Jeff slowly brought his face closer to Scarlett.

He planted a soft kiss on her lips. It was strangely gentle, making her cheeks turn red and her hazel eye turn pink.

"Pink... I wonder what that means." He chuckled, staring at her.

Zielly came running. She knocked Jeff's lights out.

"Thanks..." Scarlett said in a small voice.

"You're welcome. Don't let him take advantage of you. Stay in control."

"O-Ok. I need to go to the bathroom, do you know where it is?"

"Yeah. Lucky you, Lost Silver gave me a tour."

"Ooh, who's that?"

"...A friend..."

"Did your eyes turned pink? Did you blush? Do you like him?"

Focus: Zielly

After the whole "Love" incident, I made my way to the living room.

Ben and Lost Silver were there. Lost Silver and Ben were playing Legend of Zelda. From the looks of it, Ben was winning.

"Ah, I-I a-almost h-had you."

"Can't catch me, I'm Ben." He said in a playful voice.

Zielly chuckled at their antics.

"Are things always like this?"

"Yes, child," a voice said from behind her. "Things are always like this."

"Gah!" Zielly yelped, stumbling forwards. "Yeesh, don't scare me like that."

"Can't help it. I am a creepypasta, after all."

And with that, Slender left. Zielly shivered.

Zielly continued to watch them play.

Focus: Scarlett

Eyeless Jack had left by the time Scarlett got back.

"Rude. But, maybe he had other things to do."

"He went out for a kill." Slender said.

"Gah!" Scarlett jumped and turned around to find Slender there.

"Yeesh, don't scare me like that."

"Hilarious. Zielly said the exact same thing."

"Well, we are twins. I mean, what'd you expect?"

"Nothing more, nothing less. By the way, Sally wanted to apologize for scaring you earlier. She decided to leave the dolls she made for you and Zielly."

The same little girl from before came out from behind Slender.

"Sorry," she said in a sweet voice. She handed Scarlett the dolls.

"Thank you, but, don't you need these?" Scarlett asked. The girl shook her head.

"I can make more. Please accept my gift. I hope we can be friends." She looked up at Scarlett and smiled an adorable smile. Scarlett's hazel eye turned yellow.

"Of course."

A/N: Hey, guys!!! I'm glad I was able to update today. I was scared I wouldn't have time. I hope y'all liked this chapter. Please don't forget to vote! I have the poll in a little bit. But, right now, I want to let you know that I might not update during EOG week. But, you will be in updates heaven during the summer! Look forward to it, you guys! Not too far in the distance. 😁 Anyways, enough of my rambling. Here's the poll:

Bloody Painter

BEN

Lost Silver

Glitchy Red

Ticci Toby

Jeff

Eyeless Jack

Other

Thanks for voting and commenting! I appreciate it! Remember to vote if you want the side story! Thanks for reading!! 😊